How a Western Australian miner weighs lifecycle cost against price when it tenders trucks and excavators
Summary
- A fleet tender is read for availability before price: buyers rank reliability first because downtime costs production, and increasingly compare lifecycle cost rather than purchase price. 1
- The scale of the decisions is large: Fortescue is taking about 360 autonomous battery-electric trucks inside a 475-machine order, and the dealer or maker has to be able to maintain such a fleet. 2
- Customers trust a global maker's machine but judge the engine and the service on response speed and spares, so the brand on the truck and the brand that keeps it running can differ. 3
- The trades behind the fleet are short: a union official puts the gap at roughly 2,000 electricians and heavy diesel mechanics, while Rio Tinto outsourced about 120 in-house tradespeople roles at its Pilbara site services division. 4 5
- Dealers sell rebuilds and parts-supply deals as the lifecycle answer; one rebuild specialist backs its work with 12 months or 5,000 hours of warranty, which is a warranty, not a promise of component life. 6
- The money to buy is there: export earnings are forecast at $383 billion in 2025-26 with gold at $69 billion, but a buyer's real test is what happens when the cycle turns and maintenance gets cut. 7
Transcript
01What a buyer actually reads in a tender
You run purchasing for a mid-tier mine in Western Australia. When a truck or excavator tender lands on your desk, what do you read first?
Not the price. The price is on the sheet and everybody can read it, so it does not separate anybody. What I read for is how many hours that machine will work for me. Reliability ranks first, because every hour a truck stands is production we do not get back, and the buyers I know increasingly compare lifecycle cost rather than purchase price. 1
I should say that the tender mechanics I describe come from what mining operators elsewhere in Asia have told KIRA's analysts, and I recognise most of it. The mine planners specify the equipment from the mine plan and the production plan, purchasing invites quotes or tenders, and the board approves the capital. 8 My job is to make sure the board is approving a cost over the life of the machine, not a number on a quotation. 1
Does the scale of the biggest buyers shape what everybody else is offered?
Yes, it sets the climate. Fortescue is taking 475 zero-emission Liebherr machines, about 360 of them autonomous battery-electric trucks, 55 electric excavators and 60 battery dozers, and it already had more than 200 autonomous trucks. 2 A mid-tier buyer like me does not buy at that scale. But the makers' attention, their parts stock and their best field engineers go where the volume is, and I have to ask how much of that will reach my pit. 2
02Lifecycle cost in practice
Everybody says lifecycle cost. What does it look like on your spreadsheet?
I cannot show you our numbers, and I would not trust anybody who gave you a single figure, because it depends on the pit, the haul road, the operators and the fuel. What I can tell you is the logic. I want to know the hours a machine will be available over a run of years, what the major components will cost and when, and how fast a part turns up when something breaks. 1 A cheap truck with a slow parts line is the most expensive truck I can buy. 3
Large machines are judged on consistent availability sustained over several years, not on one good quarter. 9 So I ask for the availability the maker or dealer will stand behind, and I ask who pays when the machine misses it. A promise nobody pays for is a brochure. 9
Do you keep spare machines and parts to protect yourself?
We keep a standby fleet and safety stocks of the critical parts, because a stopped shovel starves the whole line. Some groups never retire old equipment at all; the old truck is the standby. 10 That costs money and ties up capital, so when a dealer can show that its parts line is quick enough for me to carry less stock, that is a real saving and I put it into the comparison. 10
03Machine brand, engine brand and the service behind them
Do you buy a brand, or a package?
A package, though nobody admits it. Operators trust a global maker for the reliability of the machine, but they prefer the engine or component brand with the fastest service and spares, even when that brand is not on the machine. 3 So you will hear a buyer say he likes one truck and a different engine, and both can be true. 3
Mixed fleets are normal in the big pits. At Roy Hill, Epiroc converted 78 haul trucks to driverless operation, and the press describes the autonomous fleet as a mix of 54 Caterpillar 793F and 24 Hitachi EH5000 trucks. 11 A buyer who has trucks from two makers will not want two different arguments about parts, so he judges each maker on how it behaves when the machine is down. 3
What do owners do when they do not have the skills in their own workshop?
They call the vendor. Owners with a central workshop often find that the skills for electronic engines are not there, and that is when the maker's field engineer becomes the most valuable man on site. 12 Smaller miners depend on supplier maintenance even more, because they cannot hire the people, and long-term maintenance and repair contracts with the makers have been the answer. 13
04Rebuilds, warranties and who carries the risk
Dealers keep offering you rebuilds and parts-supply deals. Are they a good answer to lifecycle cost?
Sometimes. A rebuild keeps the capital in the ground and it is quicker than waiting for a new machine. WesTrac's own blog describes a Cat Certified Rebuild as returning a machine to like-new condition, and says dealer rebuilds are not to the full certified specification but still offer performance gains and reduced cost of ownership. 14 That is the dealer's marketing, so I read it as a sales line and ask for the scope in writing. 14
Be careful with the word warranty. Mader, for one, says its rebuilds are backed by a warranty covering all workmanship and parts for 12 months or 5,000 hours. 6 That is what it says it will fix if its work fails. It is not a promise of how long a component will last in my pit, and I know the difference when I negotiate. 6 The deal I like is the one where the dealer carries part of the risk of a component not reaching its life, because then our interests point the same way. 1
What goes wrong that suppliers never see on a tender sheet?
The operating habits. Poor fuel quality and poor coolant practice shorten engine life, and they are a hidden cause of warranty disputes between the buyer and the maker. 15 And production pressure beats the maintenance plan more often than anybody puts in writing; in a deep pit the scheduled stop is the first thing to slip. 16 So when a maker tells me the component life, I ask whether that assumes we do our part. I should ask myself the same question. 15
05Labour, outsourcing and who keeps the fleet running
How much does the labour market change who maintains your fleet?
A great deal. Western Australia recorded a record 135,693 on-site full-time equivalent positions in 2024 and accounts for 47% of Australia's mining workforce, and the government estimates the Australian mining industry as a whole will need about 56,000 additional workers by 2033. 5 Recruiters tell the press there is demand for heavy-duty diesel fitters and mechanical trades, and I see that in every wage conversation. 5
One trade paper quotes a union organiser putting the gap at roughly 2,000 electricians and heavy diesel mechanics, and says automated sites run at about 65% of the staffing of non-automated sites. 4 I read that as a union estimate, not a census. But it explains why more of my maintenance questions end with a supplier's name. 4
Are the big miners outsourcing the trades?
In places, yes. Rio Tinto cut about 120 in-house tradespeople roles at its Pilbara site services division and outsourced the work to contractors. 5 One recruiter also says apprentices are often the first let go in a downturn, which leaves the industry short when demand returns. 5 For a buyer like me the lesson is not that outsourcing is right or wrong. It is that the maintenance contract is now part of the equipment decision. 13
On contract mining, what I hear from other mining markets is that owners who push most risk onto the contractor and judge bids on cost per tonne alone put off capable contractors, and some owners began to specify the equipment size the contractor must use after missed targets. 17 I would not claim that is how every Australian contract works. But I see the same temptation. 17
06The cycle, the budget and the pressure on maintenance
Is the money there for new fleet at the moment?
It depends on the commodity. The Resources and Energy Quarterly in December 2025 had export earnings at $383 billion in 2025-26, a 0.6% decline, and $374 billion in 2026-27, with gold at $69 billion in 2025-26 and $74 billion in 2026-27 and staying above US$3,500 an ounce. 7 So a gold miner and an iron ore miner sit in the same country and make very different decisions. I cannot tell you where those forecasts will be next quarter. 7
What happens to maintenance when the board feels the squeeze?
That is the part that worries me. When the price of ore falls, the cheapest thing to cut looks like the maintenance plan, and the scheduled stop is already the first thing production pushes aside. 16 The bill arrives later, in component life and in downtime. Buyers who weighed lifecycle cost when times were good tend to keep doing it when times are bad. Those who only read the price do not. 1
07Advice to a newcomer, and what would change my mind
A new maker or service company from Japan, Korea or China wants to sell into mines like yours. What should it do?
Lead with hours, not with price. Show me availability over several years on a site like mine, and show me how you will keep parts and a field engineer close to the pit. 9 Buyers trust a global name for the machine, but they will move on the engine or component if the service is faster, so that is where a newcomer can win a first order. 3
And bring the people. If I am short of electricians and diesel mechanics, a supplier who puts trained people in my workshop is worth more than a discount. 4 Liebherr says it is significantly increasing investment in branches, reman facilities, people and remote support services for its fleet in Australia, and that is the standard a newcomer will be compared with. 2
What would change your mind about buying on lifecycle cost, and what worries you?
If a supplier could show me availability and component life, with the customer's name and the operating conditions, over several years, I would take a new brand on a trial fleet tomorrow. 9 What worries me is the people. The industry is short of trades, apprentices are let go in every downturn, and a lifecycle cost on paper means nothing if nobody is there to do the work. 5 I would rather my board heard that from me than from a breakdown report. 1
Sources and basis
- 1Reliability ranks first for large mining buyers because downtime costs production; buyers increasingly compare lifecycle cost rather than purchase priceKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 2Fortescue will take 475 zero-emission Liebherr machines: about 360 autonomous battery-electric T 264 trucks, 55 R 9400 E electric excavators and 60 battery-powered dozers, roughly triple the 120 trucks announced in 2022; Fortescue already has more than 200 autonomous trucks; Liebherr-Australia says it is significantly increasing investment in branches, reman facilities, people and remote support services to maintain this fleet (Liebherr's own statement)Public source · Liebherr press release, 24 Sep 2024 · link
- 3Customers trust a global maker's machine reliability but prefer the engine brand with the fastest service and spares, even when the machine brand differsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 4Trade-press article quoting an Australian Workers Union national mining organiser: the gap is roughly 2,000 electricians and heavy diesel mechanics; automated sites run at about 65% of the staffing of non-automated sites (he cites recent reviews); the article reports a 63% fall in mining engineering enrolment since 2014 (attributed to the Australian Minerals Tertiary Education Council)Public source · The Australian Mining Review, January 2026 issue (trade press quoting a union official) · link
- 5Western Australia recorded a record 135,693 on-site full-time equivalent mining positions in 2024 and accounts for 47% of Australia's total mining workforce; the government estimates the Australian mining industry (a national figure, not WA only) will need about 56,000 additional workers by 2033; recruiters report demand for heavy-duty diesel fitters and mechanical trades; Rio Tinto cut about 120 in-house tradespeople roles from its Pilbara site services division and outsourced the work to contractors; a recruiter says apprentices are often the first let go in downturns, leaving the industry short of tradespeople when demand returnsPublic source · Mining Technology (GlobalData), 22 Aug 2025 · link
- 6Mader Group says every rebuild it carries out is backed by a warranty covering all workmanship and parts for 12 months or 5,000 hours (the company's own statement)Public source · Mader Group website, rebuild page, accessed Oct 2026 (page footer 2026) · link
- 7Resources and Energy Quarterly, December 2025: resources and energy export earnings forecast at $383 billion in 2025-26 (a 0.6% decline) and $374 billion in 2026-27; gold earnings forecast at $69 billion in 2025-26 and $74 billion in 2026-27, with gold expected to stay above US$3,500 an ounce over the outlook periodPublic source · Daily Cargo News, 19 Dec 2025, citing the Office of the Chief Economist · link
- 8The mining department specifies equipment from the mine plan and production plan; purchasing invites quotes or tenders; the board approves capital purchasesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 9Large dump trucks and shovels are judged satisfactory on consistent availability sustained over several yearsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining planning officials in South Asia
- 10Mines keep a standby fleet and safety stocks of critical parts; some groups never retire old equipmentKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 11Epiroc converted 78 haul trucks to driverless operation at Roy Hill, Hancock Iron Ore's Pilbara mine, using its LinkOA system; the article says the fully implemented autonomous fleet will include 54 Caterpillar 793F and 24 Hitachi EH5000 trucks (it also mentions 60 trucks designated for autonomous operation without reconciling the two)Public source · HeavyQuip Magazine, 28 Oct 2025 · link
- 12Owners with their own central workshops often lack skills for electronic engines and call the vendor for helpKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 13Smaller miners depend on supplier maintenance because they lack skilled staff; long-term maintenance and repair contracts with makers were emergingKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 14WesTrac blog post: a Cat Certified Rebuild is described as returning a machine to like-new condition; dealer rebuilds are not to full certified-rebuild specification but still offer performance gains and reduced cost of ownership; a Cat Certified Machine Rebuild reduces Scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions by at least 70% compared with buying a new machine, based on a Caterpillar study (the dealer's own marketing)Public source · WesTrac blog, 18 Nov 2025 · link
- 15Poor fuel quality and poor coolant practice cause premature engine failure and are a hidden cause of warranty disputesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 16In deep pits, scheduled maintenance is sometimes skipped because of production pressureKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, mining operators in South Asia
- 17Mine owners that push most risk onto contractors and judge bids on cost per tonne alone deter capable contractors; after missed targets, some owners began specifying the equipment size contractors must useKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, contract miners in South Asia