Who sets the rate on a bank's cash dollars in Indonesia: branch authority, spreads and sourcing under the new purchase cap
Summary
- The undocumented cash dollar limit was cut in steps during 2026: from 100,000 to 50,000 dollars a month per buyer in April, to 25,000 in June, and to 10,000 per person per month from 1 July. 1 2 3
- Bank Indonesia says each step cut customers' daily spot transactions and expects underlying-backed deals to reach 98.1% of the total, so the counter business that remains is the documented one. 4
- Who may quote a rate is the heart of the pricing question: banks run one of three head-office and branch models, and at some banks branches still deal quietly outside the bank with whoever pays best. 5 6
- Rates win deals and service only breaks ties, so a bank with regional note sources through correspondent banks can quote the sharpest price, while banks still carry much wider spreads than money changers on small deals. 7 8 9
- Money changers look more exposed to the new limit than banks, since their activity is mostly personal and undocumented, and their association already expects transactions to fall; 15.39 million foreign tourists in 2025 is the demand base that keeps them busy. 10 11 12
- Delivery, promotion and branch authority are cost questions: delivery is costly because of insurance and armed transport, and most volume comes from existing account holders. 13 14
Transcript
01The ceiling that moved three times
If an outsider asked what has changed most on your banknote desk this year, what would you tell them?
The question we must ask before we sell cash dollars. At the start of the year a customer could buy 100,000 dollars a month in notes without showing a reason, and from April that fell to 50,000 per buyer. 1 From 2 June it was 25,000 per month per party. 2 Since 1 July it is 10,000 per person per month. 3
Small deals still go through the teller at the posted rate, so the teller is the one who has to ask the customer first, and every time the limit moves the tellers get a circular and a short briefing before the next customer walks in. Above a small amount the deal leaves the teller's hands and goes to the branch head or a dealer at head office, who negotiate a rate. 15
Why did the central bank move in steps rather than once?
I can only give you my reading and what has been said in public. The rupiah was recorded at Rp17,730 per dollar on 17 June, so the pressure was real. 3 After the first step the deputy governor said the daily average of customers' spot transactions fell by US$16 million, and after the next step by US$9 million, so the central bank saw the lever work and pulled it again. 4
A senior colleague put it more plainly: customers do not get loyal to a rule, they get loyal to a rate. That is also why a desk like mine pays attention to what the rule does to the volume that remains, and why I read the customer's reaction at the counter before I read any statistic. Banknote trade used to be a courtesy to account holders, and now it is fee income we have to earn. 16
02Who may quote, and who may quote outside
Inside a bank, who actually has authority over a cash dollar rate?
It depends on the bank, and I can describe only the patterns. Three models live side by side. In the first, branches are fully autonomous and even compete with each other. In the second, branches buy retail and sell to head office, which sells wholesale. In the third, head office buys wholesale from abroad and the branches only sell retail. 5
Ours is closer to the third, with central funding and indicative rates from my desk, so the branches sell retail and I carry the position. I prefer it for control, though I admit the autonomous model reacts faster at the counter. Branch autonomy improves responsiveness and weakens central control of open positions, and that trade-off never goes away, however the organisation chart is drawn. A branch with its own dealer wants to own its profit and loss, and head office wants one view of the bank's position at the end of the day. 17
What do you do when a branch quotes better than your indicative rate?
Branches are supposed to settle a surplus or a shortage inside the bank. At some banks, and I am not going to say which, branches quietly deal with whoever offers the best rate, including outside parties, which is exactly what the arrangement inside the bank is meant to prevent, because the surplus at one branch should cover the shortage at another. 6
So we give branches daily position limits and my desk watches them through the day. 17 And above a small amount the customer gets a negotiated rate, which the branch head or a head-office dealer must approve, so that the quote reaches the customer with a name on it and I can answer for it when treasury asks. Nobody likes the extra phone call, but an unapproved quote on a big deal is a far worse conversation than a short delay. 15
03Spreads and what moves them
Where do bank spreads sit compared with money changers?
Wider, and everybody knows it, especially on small individual deals. 9 I cannot give you our spread, and the ones other banks use are not comparable anyway, because they depend on deal size and on cost of funds. What I can say is that customers have become rate-sensitive, and that pushed banks to cut spreads toward money changer levels. 9
Rate decides whether the customer deals at all. Once two rates are equal, service decides. 7 Banknote customers are not loyal, they remember only who posted the best rate, and banknote trade used to be a courtesy to account holders and now is fee income we have to earn. 16
Does the new limit change how you set the rate?
Not the rate itself, as far as I can see, but it changes who comes to the counter. The undocumented walk-in is the customer with the least weight in my pricing, and the documented customer arrives with a reason and less patience for a wide spread. One economist said that undocumented deals are a very small share of foreign exchange activity, so bank business will not change much, and the central bank itself expects the documented share to reach 98.1%. 10 4
I would add a caution from the shop floor: the average hides the retail counter. For the small customer who wanted notes for a trip, the answer in July was a different one from the answer in March, because from 1 July a purchase without an underlying transaction is limited to USD10,000 per participant per month. At the teller window that is a plain yes or no, and the explanation falls on the teller. 18 15
04Where the notes come from
When your own vault is short of dollars or yen, where do you go?
To the sources that cost least in time and money. A bank with access to regional banknote sources through correspondent banks can quote the most competitive rates, and that access matters more than any clever pricing. 8 Head office or another branch comes first, because that is cheap, and the regional market is the backstop. 5
A money changer's cheapest supply is quite different: customers who earn foreign cash, such as travel agents, hotels, transport firms and exporters. Buying from a bank, or from another changer, is their last resort, so a bank that wants to sell wholesale notes to changers should not expect an easy customer. Their business is built on finding the other side of each deal fast and not sitting on stock. 19
Does delivery of cash to customers matter in your business?
Less than for the changers. We see delivery and pick-up as costly because of insurance and armed transport, so we ask for a minimum amount and a request before noon. 13 Promotion is minimal as well: most of our volume comes from existing account holders, and customers follow the best rate, not the best advertisement. 14
05Money changers, tourists and the new cap
Is the new limit hitting money changers harder than banks?
That is the common expectation. An economist said money changers would be hit harder than banks, because their activity is mostly personal and undocumented. 10 Another banker said the impact would be significant only if purchases with underlying were also restricted, and that is a line the central bank has not crossed. 10
On the ground the picture is mixed. The cut to 10,000 per customer per month took effect on 1 July, it is the third reduction within a year and it also covers licensed money changers. 11 The Bali head of their association said there was no significant rise in sales or purchases despite the volatility, helped by Bali's tourist customers, while its secretary general said transactions had risen compared with 2025 and expected them to fall once the new threshold applies. 11
Where does tourism fit in?
It is a small share of banknote value, but it sits at airports, hotels and malls, where changers rather than banks are present. 20 The volume is still large: Indonesia had 15.39 million foreign tourist arrivals in 2025, above the target of 14-15 million. 12
Peaks matter too: school holidays, year-end and the pilgrimage season, when dealers hold stock expecting a higher rate, and my own desk plans cash supply around the same dates. 21 And do not forget the street traders, who undercut the formal players on rate and on hours at the retail end, with no counter and no queue. 22
06Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me
A foreign bank wants to build a banknote business in Indonesia. What should it do first?
Decide who may quote. Choose one of the three models and write it down, because a bank that leaves branch authority vague ends up competing with itself. 5 Then give the branches position limits and an indicative rate, and keep a hybrid with central funding rather than total autonomy. 17
Then source properly. If you can reach regional note supply through correspondent banks you can quote sharply, and if you cannot, do not pretend, because customers will find the better rate across the road within a day. Build the correspondent relationships first and the branch network will follow, not the other way round. 8 Do not spend heavily on promotion. Most of the volume will come from your own account holders, and they follow the best rate rather than the best advertisement, so spend your effort on the rate and on the speed of the counter. 14
What would change your mind about the business, and what worries you?
What worries me is that the rule keeps changing. The ceiling has moved three times this year, from 100,000 to 10,000 dollars a month. 10 The economist said the limit is likely to be effective only in the short term for easing volatility, and I hope he is right, because otherwise the next step could reach documented customers. 10 Another banker said the effect would be significant only then. 10
What would change my mind in the other direction is evidence that the documented share keeps rising to the 98.1% the central bank expects. 4 If it does, my job turns into pricing documented flows, and that is a different business from the walk-in counter. I would rather prepare for it now than argue with it later. 16
Sources and basis
- 1Bank Indonesia rules announced in March 2026: cash foreign exchange purchases without supporting documents capped at US$50,000 per buyer per month, down from US$100,000, effective from April; the rupiah was about 16,985 per US dollar after the decision, near record lowsPublic source · Free Malaysia Today (Bloomberg wire report), 18 Mar 2026 · link
- 2Under PADG No. 11/2026, signed on 26 May 2026, cash purchases of foreign currency with rupiah without an underlying transaction are capped at US$25,000 per month per party in the foreign exchange market, down from US$50,000, effective 2 June 2026; in 2015 Bank Indonesia had cut the monthly cash limit from US$100,000 to US$25,000; forward purchases stay at US$100,000 per month per partyPublic source · CNBC Indonesia, 3 Jun 2026 · link
- 3Bank Indonesia policy release after the board meeting of 17-18 June 2026: a lower threshold for cash purchases of foreign exchange against the Rupiah without underlying transactions, to USD10,000 per person per month, effective from 1 July 2026; the Rupiah was recorded at Rp17,730 per US dollar on 17 June 2026Public source · Bank Indonesia, news release, June 2026 · link
- 4At the press conference of 18 June 2026 a Bank Indonesia deputy governor said that lowering the threshold to US$50,000 cut the daily average of customers' spot transactions by US$16 million, and that the next step cut it by US$9 million; the new limit is US$10,000 per person per month from 1 July 2026; Bank Indonesia expects underlying-backed transactions to reach 98.1% of total foreign exchange transactionsPublic source · CNBC Indonesia, 18 Jun 2026 · link
- 5Three head office and branch models coexist: fully autonomous branches that even compete with each other; branches that buy retail and sell to head office, which sells wholesale; and head office buying wholesale abroad while branches sell retailKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 6Branches are supposed to settle surpluses and shortages within the bank, but at some banks branches quietly deal with whoever offers the best rateKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 7Rate decides whether a customer deals or not; once rates are equal, service decidesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian banks and money changers
- 8Banks with access to regional banknote sources through correspondent banks can quote the most competitive ratesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 9Banks quote much wider spreads than money changers, especially on small individual transactions, and customers who became rate-sensitive pushed banks to cut spreads toward money changer levelsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks and money changers
- 10Kontan, 21 June 2026: the limit on purchases of foreign currency without underlying was US$100,000 per month at the start of 2026 and was cut in steps to US$10,000; an economist at a Jakarta think tank said non-underlying transactions are a very small share of foreign exchange activity so bank business will not change much, and expected money changers to be hit harder than banks because their activity is mostly non-underlying personal transactions; a bank president director said the impact would be significant only if purchases with underlying were also restricted; a money changer branch head said he had heard the rule applied only to banks for now; Bank Indonesia estimates underlying-based transactions will exceed 98% of the total; the economist said the limit is likely to be effective only in the short term for easing rupiah volatilityPublic source · Kontan, 21 Jun 2026 · link
- 11Kontan, around 1 July 2026: the cut from US$25,000 to US$10,000 per customer per month took effect on 1 July 2026, the third reduction within a year, and also covers licensed non-bank money changers (KUPVA BB), which had been at US$25,000; BCA said on 1 July 2026 it had already applied the US$10,000 threshold; the Bali head of the money changers' association said there was no significant rise in foreign currency sales or purchases despite exchange rate volatility, helped by Bali's tourism-dependent customer base; its secretary general said transactions had risen compared with 2025 and expected them to fall once the US$10,000 threshold appliesPublic source · Kontan, Jul 2026 (association officials quoted) · link
- 12Foreign tourist arrivals to Indonesia in 2025 were 15.39 million, above the government's target of 14-15 million, as reported by the Tourism Minister at a House of Representatives commission meeting; tourism foreign exchange earnings for 2025 were projected to rise 13.17% from 2024Public source · ANTARA News, 4 Feb 2026 · link
- 13Banks see delivery and pick-up as costly because of insurance and armed transport, so they require a minimum amount and a request before noonKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 14Banks hardly promote banknote trade: customers follow the best rate, and most volume comes from existing account holdersKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 15Small deals are settled by tellers at posted rates; above a threshold the customer gets a negotiated rate approved by the branch head or a head office dealerKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 16Banknote trade used to be a courtesy to account holders; banks now treat it as fee income they have to earn, and the customers are not loyal: they only remember who posted the best rateKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian banks and money changers
- 17Branch-level autonomy improves responsiveness but weakens central control of open positions; branches have daily position limits that head office monitors, and the practical model is a hybrid with central funding and indicative ratesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian forex banks
- 18BCA customer notice dated 1 July 2026: from 1 July 2026 cash purchases of foreign currency against the Rupiah without an underlying transaction are limited to USD10,000 per participant per month; the threshold for supporting documents on outgoing foreign currency transfers falls from more than USD50,000 to more than USD25,000; the notice cites PADG No. 13 of 2026 and PADG No. 15 of 2026 (the bank's own notice)Public source · BCA website, customer information, 1 Jul 2026 · link
- 19Most money changers are daily traders who avoid open positions and look for a counter trade to back every deal; their cheapest supply is customers who earn foreign cash, such as travel agents, hotels, transport firms and exporters; buying from banks or other changers is a last resortKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian money changers
- 20Tourist trade is a small share of banknote value but concentrated at airports, hotels and malls, where money changers rather than banks are presentKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian money changers and market observers
- 21Demand peaks around school holidays, year-end and the pilgrimage season, and dealers hold stock ahead of the peaks expecting higher ratesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian money changers
- 22Informal street traders compete with money changers on rate and hours at the retail endKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesian money changers