Animal feed and additives: who buys — what practitioners say
Who decides
Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.
Who specifies
No field statement yet
Who buys and pays
- Small feed mills often mix premixes bought from bigger producers, leave the additive choice to the premix supplier and switch vendors for the lowest price of the day. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market)
- Sub-agents sell to the farmers around their own ponds, often from a village feed shop, and they know who pays and who does not. feed agents · KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra)
- Agents extend credit only to farmers whose ponds they have seen and to sub-agents with steady month-end numbers; new farmers pay cash. feed agents · KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra)
- Integrators want measurable on-farm results and rely on their own laboratories rather than on suppliers' technical advice. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market)
- Large feed groups have in-house nutritionists and stable supplier relationships, and their costs are driven by bulk ingredients, so they are less price sensitive about additives. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market)
- Some producers resist swapping an ingredient for a better one because the label figure looks worse to farm buyers, so the bag buyer must be convinced as well as the formulator. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market)
Who carries the risk
No field statement yet
Companies in these roles, listed by BizDirect Asia: Distributor list · Manufacturer list · Manufacturer list · Manufacturer list
Thailand
- Small feed mills often mix premixes bought from bigger producers, leave the additive choice to the premix supplier and switch vendors for the lowest price of the day. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market) · Selling feed additives on proof in Thailand: trials, seminars and technical sales against cheaper rivals
- Integrators want measurable on-farm results and rely on their own laboratories rather than on suppliers' technical advice. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market) · Selling feed additives on proof in Thailand: trials, seminars and technical sales against cheaper rivals
- Large feed groups have in-house nutritionists and stable supplier relationships, and their costs are driven by bulk ingredients, so they are less price sensitive about additives. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market) · Selling feed additives on proof in Thailand: trials, seminars and technical sales against cheaper rivals
- Some producers resist swapping an ingredient for a better one because the label figure looks worse to farm buyers, so the bag buyer must be convinced as well as the formulator. technical sales managers at feed additive distributors · KIRA field research (interviews with feed producers, additive suppliers and livestock farms in another large Asian feed market) · Selling feed additives on proof in Thailand: trials, seminars and technical sales against cheaper rivals
Indonesia
- Sub-agents sell to the farmers around their own ponds, often from a village feed shop, and they know who pays and who does not. feed agents · KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra) · How fish feed moves from mill to pond in Java: agents, sub-agents, per-kg incentives and the month-end tonnage line
- Agents extend credit only to farmers whose ponds they have seen and to sub-agents with steady month-end numbers; new farmers pay cash. feed agents · KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra) · How fish feed moves from mill to pond in Java: agents, sub-agents, per-kg incentives and the month-end tonnage line
Related answers
Why do fish farmers in Indonesia switch feed brands?
Switching costs little, so farmers buy a few sacks from another brand to see how fish behave, and they leave a brand after an inconsistent batch, per KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra).
Source: KIRA field research (modelled interview) · How fish feed moves from mill to pond in Java: agents, sub-agents, per-kg incentives and the month-end tonnage line
Do fish prices change how much feed farmers buy in Indonesia?
Yes: when fish prices fall farmers trade down to cheaper feed, and when prices rise they stock more and expand, per KIRA field research (interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra).
Source: KIRA field research (modelled interview) · How fish feed moves from mill to pond in Java: agents, sub-agents, per-kg incentives and the month-end tonnage line