Distribution & channels · Expert interview

How fish feed moves from mill to pond in Java: agents, sub-agents, per-kg incentives and the month-end tonnage line

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Indonesia
Industry
Aquaculture feed
Length
≈ 30 min read
GPMT (Indonesian feedmills association)Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with feed-mill sales staff, feed agents and sub-agents, fish farmers and fisheries officials across Java and Sumatra, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts; every figure comes from a public source, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • Fish feed does not have one price but a ladder, and the agent's real earnings sit in a per-kg incentive that grows with monthly tonnage, so the month-end volume line steers the whole business. 1 2
  • The pool the ladder serves is large: 1.43 million tonnes of fish feed was produced in 2025, mainly for catfish, tilapia, carp, milkfish and pangasius, and mill capacity sits on Java. 3 4
  • Farmers hop brands because switching costs little, so mills fight for quality consistency, feed conversion claims and, above all, for the agents themselves with credit terms and richer incentives. 5 6 7
  • Feed is 60-70 percent of farming cost, which is why a small rise in the feed price can wipe out a small farm's profit: one 2025 catfish study puts the break-point at a feed price rise of 10.12% or 9.81%. 8 9
  • Challengers grow by luring a leader's sub-agents into becoming agents of their own, rather than building a network from scratch. 10
  • Weather and fish prices set the volume: about 100 tons of fish died at Jatiluhur in February 2025, GPMT expected lower fish feed demand as climate disrupted production cycles, and farmers trade down when fish prices fall. 11 3 12

Transcript

01A ladder of prices, not a price

KAKIRA Analyst

You are a feed agent in West Java. Walk me through how a bag of fish feed gets from the mill to a pond.

EXExpert

First thing outsiders get wrong: there is no single price. There is a ladder. The mill sells to me at one price, I sell to a sub-agent at another, I sell direct to a farmer at a third, and my sub-agent sells to his farmers at a fourth. 1 On top of each step there is a per-kg discount, and the discount depends on whether I reach the minimum tonnage the mill sets for the month. 1

And the discount is not even where I make my money. The mill adds a per-kg incentive on top, and the more tonnes I move in the month, the bigger that incentive. 2 So every few days I check where the month-end line stands, and in the last week I will push a few extra tonnes to a sub-agent at a thin price just to cross the next step. 2 A newcomer who only looks at the list price will never understand why an agent sells below it. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

How big is the pool this ladder serves?

EXExpert

Big. The feedmills association's figures for 2025, as reported this year, have fish feed at 1.43 million tonnes, mainly for catfish, tilapia, carp, milkfish and pangasius. 3 On the farm side, the fisheries ministry says national aquaculture production reached 5.02 million tons by the third quarter of 2025, and that tilapia is concentrated in Java. 13

Mill capacity sits on Java too, so for a West Java agent the truck rides are short compared with the islands. 4 That is an advantage and a trap: when every mill can reach you in a day, every mill can also reach your sub-agents in a day. 4

02Agent, sub-agent and the truck in between

KAKIRA Analyst

What is the difference between an agent and a sub-agent in practice?

EXExpert

The agent buys from the mill and holds the mill's agency. The sub-agent, in Indonesian the sub-agen, buys from the agent and sells to the farmers around his own ponds, often from a feed shop, a toko pakan, in the village. 1 I can sell to farmers directly as well, and I do for the bigger ones, but the sub-agent knows who pays and who does not. 1

Both of us get the per-kg incentive, and both of us get more of it the more we move. 2 That is why the relationship between agent and sub-agent is closer than it looks from outside. If my sub-agents fall behind, my own month-end line falls behind, and so does my incentive. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

Who carries the feed? Do the mills run their own trucks?

EXExpert

No. The mills deliver through hired transport companies rather than their own fleets. 14 From my warehouse I use hired trucks as well, and the driver knows more about the roads and the ponds than I do. The practical effect is that delivery timing is a service I sell, not a cost I can ignore: a farmer whose fish are hungry will call another shop within an hour. 14

03Why a farmer buys one brand today and another tomorrow

KAKIRA Analyst

How loyal are farmers to a brand?

EXExpert

Not very. Switching costs nothing: the farmer buys a few sacks from another brand next week and sees how the fish behave. Our buyers have a lot of bargaining power for exactly that reason. 5 The only thing that holds them is a feed that behaves the same in every sack. When one batch is different from the last, they punish it quickly, and punishing means leaving. 15

So my stock rotation is part of the product. If I sell a farmer a sack that sat in a hot warehouse and the pellets are broken, he does not blame the heat. He blames the brand, and then he blames me. 15

KAKIRA Analyst

What do the mills say to convince farmers, then?

EXExpert

Feed conversion: how many kilograms of fish for each kilogram of feed. That is the sales argument. Floating feed claims the better conversion, and sinking feed is the cheaper sack. 6 Industry people keep saying the same thing in public: a recent industry event heard that any change in formulation or process must bring the conversion ratio down. 8

A good farmer measures this himself, so he trusts his own pond more than any leaflet. I have learned to say: try one pond, keep your records, compare after a cycle. 6 It sells more than any discount, because the farmer who proves it to himself stays longer than the farmer who was talked into it. 5

04Money: cost, credit and the thin margin of the farmer

KAKIRA Analyst

What does feed mean to a farmer's budget?

EXExpert

Everything. An industry consultant said at an event in Jakarta last year that feed is the biggest cost in aquaculture, 60-70 percent of the farming cost. 8 When the feed price moves, the farmer's whole year moves. A farmer I know in another province told a local newspaper that feed now costs about Rp 500,000 a sack of 50 kg, up from Rp 450,000, and that factory feed alone leaves only a small profit. 16 That is Kalimantan, not Java, so use it for the direction, not for my prices. 16

A catfish feasibility study from last year found that a small farm tips into losses if the feed price rises by 10.12% or 9.81%, or if the selling price falls by 4.77% or 4.63%. 9 That study is from Central Java and for a home-scale farm, but it is how my customers feel. A small move on either side and the margin is gone. 9

KAKIRA Analyst

Do you give farmers credit? And does the mill give you credit?

EXExpert

I cannot give you my own terms. It depends on the customer and on the mill. What I can say is the structural part: credit terms and incentive schemes are the main levers the mills use to win agents, and the agent in turn uses the same lever on sub-agents and farmers. 7 Whoever carries the credit carries the risk, and when fish prices fall the first thing a farmer delays is the feed payment. 12

So credit is a tool and a hazard. I give it to farmers whose ponds I have seen with my own eyes and to sub-agents whose month-end numbers have been steady. A new farmer pays cash until I know him. 7

05The fight for the sub-agent

KAKIRA Analyst

What does competition between mills look like from your desk?

EXExpert

A challenger mill does three things. It undercuts the leader's price, it offers credit terms, and it goes after the leader's sub-agents. 10 The third one hurts the most. It does not build a network from scratch: it phones my best sub-agent and offers him a direct agency, so that he becomes an agent himself, with his own discount ladder. 10

My defence is the incentive. If my sub-agent can earn more per kg staying under me than going alone, he stays. 2 But the mills with better incentive schemes and easier credit win agents, and the agent follows what the mill pays. 7

KAKIRA Analyst

Is there price pressure on the feed itself right now?

EXExpert

Not in the headline. In the 2025 figures from the feedmills association, no changes were reported in fish feed prices. 3 But the same report says much of the new capacity has come from Chinese investment, with fish feed capacity up about 8% in recent years. 3 More capacity chasing a flat volume is exactly what makes a mill call my sub-agents. 10

06When the weather or the fish price turns

KAKIRA Analyst

What events really move your volumes?

EXExpert

Three things: weather, disease and fish price. Take the weather. In February 2025 around 100 tons of fish, mostly common carp, died in floating net cages at Jatiluhur, worth about Rp 2.2 billion at an assumed Rp 22,000 per kilogram. Officials blamed extreme weather and upwelling that took the oxygen out of the water, and also said the cages exceeded capacity. 11 One farmer told local press her loss was at least Rp 200 million. 17

For me a mass death is a visible hole in the feed volume. A farmer who loses a cycle buys no feed and, if he owes me money, pays slowly. Disease does the same: an outbreak cuts feed volume sharply in the affected region. 18 I keep my exposure to any single reservoir limited for this reason. 18

KAKIRA Analyst

And fish prices?

EXExpert

They set the mood of the whole channel. When the fish price falls, farmers trade down to cheaper feed. When it rises, they stock more and expand. 12 The unstable price is also the main reason farmers hold back from expanding. 19

Right now the association itself expected lower fish feed demand, because climate change disrupted freshwater production cycles, and it said stocking resumed in January 2026, especially for pangasius. 3 I would say the same from the counter: the demand is there, but the timing is less predictable than before. 19

07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

A new feed brand wants to enter Java. How should it build a channel?

EXExpert

Start with the agents, not the farmers. Agents are the lever the mills fight over, and they respond to credit terms and a sound incentive scheme. 7 Make the incentive grow with monthly volume, because that is how an agent thinks about his month. 2 And make the quality the same in every sack, because buyers punish inconsistency faster than anything else. 15

Do not expect to win by price alone. A challenger can undercut, but the farmer can switch back as easily as he came. 5 What lasts is the sub-agent who earns more with you and the farmer whose records say your feed converts well. 6 And be ready for the leader to answer by calling your sub-agents. 10

KAKIRA Analyst

What would change your mind, and what worries you?

EXExpert

What would change my mind is a mill that could prove its quality is the same in every batch. Then farmers would stop hopping, and my business would be about service instead of price. 15 What worries me is a spiral: farmers hold back because of unstable fish prices, volumes drop, mills compete harder for fewer tonnes, and the agents end up carrying the credit. 19 7

The association expects feed production to grow 9.8% in 2026, and I hope it is right. 3 But I have seen weather take a hundred tons of fish in a week. 11 An agent who bets everything on the growth forecast, and not on his own sub-agents and his own cash, will not be around to see it. 18

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    Fish feed is sold down a ladder of prices: factory to agent, agent to sub-agent, agent to farmer and sub-agent to farmer, with per-kg discounts tied to a monthly minimum tonnage
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  2. 2
    Agents and sub-agents receive a per-kg incentive on top of the discount, larger for bigger monthly volumes
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  3. 3
    Per GPMT (the Indonesian feedmills association) data reported for 2025: total fish and shrimp feed production rose 1% to 1.84 million tonnes, comprising about 0.4 million tonnes of shrimp feed and 1.43 million tonnes of fish feed, the fish feed mainly for catfish, tilapia, carp, milkfish and pangasius; installed capacity rose about 8% for fish feed and 5% for shrimp feed in recent years, with much of the investment coming from China; no changes were reported in fish or shrimp feed prices; GPMT expected lower fish feed demand because climate change disrupted freshwater fish production cycles, with stocking resuming in January 2026, especially for pangasius; GPMT expects feed production to grow 9.8% in 2026
    Public source · Aqua Culture Asia Pacific, 'Aquafeeds in 2025: Disrupted by tariffs', 30 Jun 2026 · link
  4. 4
    Feed production capacity is concentrated on Java
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  5. 5
    Farmers switch feed brands easily because switching cost is low, so the bargaining power of the buyer is high
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  6. 6
    Feed is marketed on feed conversion, meaning the weight of fish produced per kilogram of feed, and floating feed claims a better conversion than sinking feed
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  7. 7
    Credit terms and better incentive schemes are the main levers mills use to win agents
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  8. 8
    At an aquaculture industry event in Jakarta on 27 May 2025, a technical consultant of a US soybean export council said feed is the largest cost component in aquaculture, reaching 60-70 percent of farming costs; the chairman of the feedmills association said any change in formulation or production process must lower the feed conversion ratio
    Public source · All Fish News, 28 May 2025 · link
  9. 9
    A 2025 feasibility study of a home-scale catfish farm in Purworejo (Central Java) finds the business becomes unfeasible under a selling price drop of 4.77% and 4.63% or a feed price rise of 10.12% and 9.81% (switching value analysis, two investment scenarios)
    Public source · IPB University repository, 2025 study of a Purworejo catfish business · link
  10. 10
    Challenger mills undercut the leader's price, offer credit terms and lure the leader's sub-agents to become their own agents instead of building networks from scratch
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  11. 11
    In February 2025 about 100 tons of fish, mostly common carp, died in floating net cages at Jatiluhur reservoir (West Java), valued at about Rp 2.2 billion at an assumed Rp 22,000 per kilogram; officials cited extreme weather and upwelling that sharply reduced dissolved oxygen, and said the floating net cages did not meet standards and were stocked beyond capacity
    Public source · Republika, 10 Feb 2025 · link
  12. 12
    When fish prices fall, farmers trade down to cheaper feed; when fish prices rise, they stock more and expand
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  13. 13
    Through the third quarter of 2025, national aquaculture production reached 5.02 million tons, or 96.95% of the annual target, according to the Director General of Aquaculture at the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries; the government expects the year-end total to exceed 5.1 million tons; tilapia production is concentrated in Java, followed by NTB and then Sulawesi
    Public source · CNBC Indonesia, 15 Dec 2025 · link
  14. 14
    Mills deliver through hired couriers and transport companies rather than their own fleets
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  15. 15
    Inconsistent quality is the main weakness that buyers punish
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  16. 16
    In Tenggarong, East Kalimantan (not Java), a fish farmer said a 50 kg bag of feed now costs about Rp 500,000 depending on type and quality, up from Rp 450,000; the farmer sometimes mixes alternative feed made from corn, bran and ground intestines with factory feed to cut costs, and said factory feed alone leaves only a small profit
    Public source · KutaiRaya.com, 16 Jul 2025 · link
  17. 17
    On 7 Feb 2025 detikJabar reported thousands of dead carp, patin and tilapia floating in nearly every floating net cage at Jatiluhur after continuous rain, no sunlight and wind made the water cold and murky; one farmer estimated her losses at at least Rp 200 million
    Public source · detikJabar, 7 Feb 2025 · link
  18. 18
    Disease outbreaks cut feed volume sharply in the affected regions
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel
  19. 19
    Unstable fish prices are the main reason farmers hesitate to expand
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Java fish feed channel

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Animal feed and additives in Indonesia · Animal feed and additives: risks across Asia · Animal feed and additives: pricing across Asia · Animal feed and additives: sales channels across Asia · Animal feed and additives: who buys across Asia