Commercial and industrial lighting: who decides — what practitioners say
Who decides
Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.
Who specifies
- Contractors are the actual purchasers of lighting: they propose brands for approval through their own supplier networks. main contractors on building projects · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- Advertising barely moves plant buyers, who decide after testing a few free samples on one bay for several weeks. plant facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets)
- Lighting designers carry the most weight on facade and feature lighting. lighting designers · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- The payer, the specifier and the purchaser of lighting are usually different people, so a maker must work all three to win a building project. developers, consultants and facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- A developer's retrofit decision rests on return on investment, and the brand the contractor brings is secondary as long as it can be proven. developers and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- Specifiers set the lighting performance but on large projects rarely name a brand; on small retrofits they may refer one or two. architects and M&E consultants · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- Developers decide on budget, output and the return from energy savings, and seldom care about the brand. developers and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore)
- Factories often repeat the lamp they already have because colour and brightness must match across a production floor. plant facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets)
Who buys and pays
- When lamps fail, end users call the contractor rather than the person who drew the plan, so contractors choose what works. lighting contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets)
Who carries the risk
- Contractors are held responsible for product failures, so they follow recommended lists and repeat brands they know. lighting contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets)
Companies in these roles, listed by BizDirect Asia: Supplier list · Manufacturer list · Supplier list · Manufacturer list · Supplier list · Manufacturer list
Vietnam
- Advertising barely moves plant buyers, who decide after testing a few free samples on one bay for several weeks. plant facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets) · Why Vietnamese factories repeat the lamp they know, test samples before switching, and trust their own meter
- Factories often repeat the lamp they already have because colour and brightness must match across a production floor. plant facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with plant managers, building engineers and lighting contractors in other Asian markets) · Why Vietnamese factories repeat the lamp they know, test samples before switching, and trust their own meter
Singapore
- Lighting designers carry the most weight on facade and feature lighting. lighting designers · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore) · Who really picks the light fittings in a Singapore building project: developer, consultant or contractor
- The payer, the specifier and the purchaser of lighting are usually different people, so a maker must work all three to win a building project. developers, consultants and facilities managers · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore) · Who really picks the light fittings in a Singapore building project: developer, consultant or contractor
- A developer's retrofit decision rests on return on investment, and the brand the contractor brings is secondary as long as it can be proven. developers and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore) · Who really picks the light fittings in a Singapore building project: developer, consultant or contractor
- Specifiers set the lighting performance but on large projects rarely name a brand; on small retrofits they may refer one or two. architects and M&E consultants · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore) · Who really picks the light fittings in a Singapore building project: developer, consultant or contractor
- Developers decide on budget, output and the return from energy savings, and seldom care about the brand. developers and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with developers, M&E consultants and lighting designers in Singapore) · Who really picks the light fittings in a Singapore building project: developer, consultant or contractor