Who really picks the filter inside an independent Melbourne workshop, from parts-van drops to warranty worries
Summary
- Independent workshops now carry 60% of all service and repair activity across about 27,700 sites, and most owners accept the workshop's choice of filter without asking for a brand. 1 2
- The brand on the car is usually the one on the morning delivery: workshops value stock, several drops a day and a driver they know above brand marketing, and will call the other supplier if the part is not there before lunch. 3
- House brands priced well below the leader are the distributors' growth lever, and franchise rebates tied to loyalty push counter staff towards them. 4 5 6
- Warranty fear is the workshop's selling problem: more than 40 percent of consumers believe they lose cover by servicing outside the dealer, and some 10-year warranties are tied to dealer servicing. 7 8
- The fleet is old and still engine-driven: a median age of 11.4 years, 67.3% petrol and 0.7% battery electric or hydrogen, even though EVs took 13.1% of new sales in 2025. 9 10
- Right to Repair is linked by the Treasury review to $2.4 billion a year of extra industry turnover, while the average cost of each service and repair fell from $280 in 2021 to $250 in 2024. 11 12
Transcript
01Who really picks the filter
When a car comes in for a standard service, who decides which oil filter goes on it?
Not the customer, and that surprises outsiders. Somebody books a service, asks what it costs, and that's about the whole conversation. Hardly anybody asks for a brand, and most people simply accept what we recommend, which makes the workshop the real brand decision-maker whether we like to say so or not. 2
Inside the shop it's me setting the habit and the techs following it. In practice the habit is mostly whatever the parts van dropped this morning, because that's what is on the shelf within arm's reach when the car is up on the hoist. 3
How big a part of Australian servicing is a shop like yours these days, and does that matter to the filter makers?
Bigger than the dealers like to admit. The aftermarket association's research says independents now account for 60% of all service and repair activity, that their market share in consumer-vehicle servicing has grown 10% over the past three years, and that there are about 27,700 independent workshops. 1 So the filter choices made in our bays, one car at a time, add up to a very large share of what the brand owners sell. 2
And it's not a glamorous decision. Nobody sits down and compares filter media. The tech has a car on the hoist, a customer waiting and a box in his hand, and whichever brand is in the box on the day gets fitted. 2
02The van, the account and the counter
Walk me through a normal morning. How do the parts arrive, and what makes you drop a supplier?
First thing I've got the day's jobs, and the order goes to the counter at my supplier before the first car is up. Then the vans run all day. The supplier that keeps my business is the one that delivers several times a day, has the part in stock, and sends a driver who knows where my back door is. That matters more to me than any brand flyer or promotion. 3
If the part isn't here before lunch, I ring the other supplier. That isn't disloyalty, it's a car sitting on a hoist with the customer waiting and a bay that isn't earning. What makes me move the account for good is price and quality. A wrong or poor part once, I'll forgive. Twice, and the account moves. 13
The big parts groups have been reshuffling their networks. Do you feel that in the shop?
As a change in the delivery window and sometimes the driver, yes. I can't see inside their business, but the listed group said in its FY25 full-year results that it had exited or relocated 70 sites, including consolidating 23 smaller warehouses, and still grew its trade revenue by 1.3%. 14 So the trade side is where they are putting their effort, and what I watch is the quality of the morning drop. The rep who turns up to talk about a promotion doesn't shift me. The van that turns up when it said it would does. 3
03House brands and what the techs reach for
Distributors push their own house brands now. How do those land in your shop, and do the counter staff steer you?
They show up on the counter screen as the cheaper line, and the counter person will mention them. The big groups have been growing by buying workshops and stores, franchising retail outlets and launching house brands priced well below the leading brand. 4 On an older, cheaper car where nobody is going to compare, I'm happy with a house label if the quality is there. Where the owner is fussy or the car is newer, I stay with the known name. 13
And yes, there's a lean. Franchise stores give their members rebates tied to buying loyalty and store standards, so a franchise counter pushes its own label. 5 The filter makers grumble that the house brands push their products down the priority list at the counter, and from where I stand that sounds right. 6
When nobody's watching, what does the tech reach for? And does any one brand cover every car?
What's closest, and what he trusts. Habit travels down the bay, because the apprentice copies the older tech. If a brand bites someone once, a leaking housing or a seal that doesn't seat, it's off my shelf for good. I won't argue with a tech who's had a car back up on the hoist. 2
As for one brand covering everything, none does. Nobody has a full catalogue for the mix of cars we see in Australia, so there's always the job where my preferred brand simply doesn't list the filter and I take whoever does. Range breadth wins more accounts than people think. 15
04What goes on the invoice
How do you price a filter into a service, and are customers more price-focused than before?
I look around the neighbourhood. I know roughly what the retail shops near me charge for the same filter, and I price against that rather than against my own cost. 16 The customer sees one service price, not a filter price, and I can't tell you my margins, but I'd sooner keep a customer for years than squeeze an extra few dollars out of an air filter. 16
You can see the squeeze in the numbers the aftermarket association publishes. The average cost of each service and repair was $280 in 2021 and had slid to $250 in 2024, across a car parc of 19.7 million vehicles. 12 I can't prove why, but it matches what I see at the counter, where I price against the shops around me and can't drift far from them. 16
05The warranty worry
Do customers worry that servicing with you will void the warranty?
All the time, especially on newer cars. The aftermarket association says industry surveys show more than 40 percent of consumers believe they will lose their warranty if they don't service with the dealer. 7 And some carmakers sell extended warranties of up to 10 years with dealer servicing required for the full term. 7
So at the counter, a lot of my job is reassurance. I use parts that meet the maker's specification, I do the service to the schedule and I record it properly, and I explain that to the owner in plain words. I'm not a lawyer, so if they've got a particular extended warranty I tell them to read its conditions. 2
Where does that cost you work, and where do you win it back?
Longer new-car warranties and more complex servicing pull work back to the dealer while the car is young. 8 Then the owner of a mid-range Japanese, Korean or locally built car comes to us once the warranty ends, and that's my bread and butter. European-car owners tend to stay with the dealer a lot longer, so I get fewer of them, and I wouldn't pretend otherwise. 17 What I do is make the first visit after the warranty ends as easy as I can: I show the old filter next to the new one, I write the brand on the invoice, and I tell them straight what I'd leave alone. A newcomer who feels looked after tends to come back. 2
06An older fleet, electric cars and Right to Repair
What does the age of the fleet do to your filter business?
It's good for us. The median age of cars and SUVs is now 11.4 years, and about 67.3% of the fleet is still petrol and 29% diesel. 9 Older engine cars mean oil, air and fuel filters on a regular rhythm, and the more owners hand the job to a workshop instead of doing it in the driveway, the better it is for a shop like mine. 18 The old driveway mechanic is a fading figure. People would rather pay someone, get a stamp in the book and be done, and that puts the filter decision in our hands even more than before. 18 2
And electric cars? Is that the threat everyone says it is?
The trend is real. Electric vehicles took 13.1% of new car sales in 2025, up from 9.6% the year before. 10 But on the road they're still only 2% of all cars, with more than 410,000 EVs counted as of September 2025. 19
It's a long runway, though I can't tell you how fast it ends, and it depends on what each shop works on. Hybrids still have an engine to filter, and they're 2.2% of the fleet, with battery electric or hydrogen on 0.7%. 9
What did Right to Repair change for a workshop like yours?
The scheme has been in force since 1 July 2022, and the government review said it cut inaccessible repairs by 40% and added $2.4 billion in turnover. 20 The Treasury review, in the ministers' release, says independents report greater capability, productivity and profitability, and consumers have more choice. 11 For filters it's indirect. I can't put a number on my own shop, but the review says consumers face fewer barriers servicing modern vehicles, and that is good for a shop like mine. 11
07Advice to a newcomer
A Japanese or Korean filter maker wants to sell to independents like yours. What should they do?
Get on the van. Be in the distributor's catalogue with a full range and stock in the local warehouse, because I won't order direct. 3 Then think about the counter staff, because the distributors expect the brand owner to fund the flyers, the catalogues and the technical information the counter uses to sell. 21 Cover the range, because gaps cost you the account. 15
Don't expect a rebate to move me. Price and quality are why I change supplier. 13 And remember that the workshop is the decision-maker on the day, so the brand has to earn the trust of the tech on the hoist, not just the owner. 2 Send someone who can talk about fitment and failure modes, not just a brochure. If your technical person can stand at my bench and show why the seal or the media is better, the apprentice will remember it, and habit does the rest of the selling for you. 21 2
Last one. What worries you most about the next few years?
Two things. The dealers pulling servicing back with long warranties and fine print, because that fear is real among owners. 7 8 And the electric share, since I can't tell you how quickly it eats into the engine-car servicing that pays my wages, but new sales reached 13.1% of the market in 2025. 10
Sources and basis
- 1AAAA research with Fifth Quadrant: independent workshops account for 60% of all service and repair activities, with a 10% increase in market share for independents servicing consumer vehicles over the past three years; there are 27,700 independent workshops, up 12% over the last five years; the sector spends an average $10 billion a year on service and repair, 70% consumer vehicles and 30% fleetPublic source · Australian Automotive Aftermarket Association, 29 Jul 2024 · link
- 2Most car owners follow the workshop's recommendation and few ask for a filter brand, so the workshop is the real brand decision makerKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 3Workshops buy from distributors that deliver several times a day; stock availability, reliable staff and delivery frequency matter more to them than marketing support, and if a part cannot be delivered before lunch they call the other distributorKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 4Distributors grow by acquiring workshops and stores, franchising retail outlets and launching house brands priced well below the leading brandKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 5Franchise retail networks give members marketing rebates tied to purchase loyalty and store standardsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 6Filter brand owners worry that distributors' house brands reduce the sales priority given to their own productsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 7AAAA on 'warranty creep': industry surveys show more than 40 percent of consumers believe they will lose their warranty if they do not service with the dealer; some carmakers offer 10-year extended warranties whose full term requires servicing at their dealerships (one brand advertises 10 years or 250,000 km)Public source · Australian Automotive Aftermarket Association, 18 Aug 2025 · link
- 8Longer new-vehicle warranties and more complex servicing pull work back to dealer workshopsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 9Median age of cars and SUVs is now 11.4 years; BITRE fleet mix: petrol 67.3%, diesel 29%, hybrid 2.2%, battery electric or hydrogen fuel cell 0.7%Public source · GoAuto, 18 Nov 2025 · link
- 10Electric vehicles reached 13.1% of new car sales in Australia in 2025, up from 9.6% in 2024; EV sales grew 38% on 2024; the record monthly share was 16.7% in December 2025Public source · AfMA, 14 Jan 2026 · link
- 11Treasury's review of the Motor Vehicle Service and Repair Information Sharing Scheme, released 6 Feb 2026, links the scheme (in place since July 2022) to a $2.4 billion annual increase in automotive industry turnover; independent workshops report greater capability, productivity and profitability, and consumers have more choice and fewer barriers when servicing modern vehiclesPublic source · Australian Government ministers' media release, 6 Feb 2026 · link
- 12AAAA: Australia's car parc is 19.7 million vehicles; the average cost of each service and repair fell from $280 in 2021 to $250 in 2024Public source · Australian Automotive Aftermarket Association, 15 Jul 2024 · link
- 13Price and quality are the main reasons a workshop would switch distributorKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 14Bapcor FY25 results: Trade segment revenue up 1.3% on FY24; the company exited or relocated 70 sites, including consolidating 23 smaller warehouses, and opened new state-based distribution centresPublic source · Bapcor ASX release, FY25 results, 29 Aug 2025 · link
- 15No filter supplier has a full catalogue for Australia's wide mix of models, so range breadth is a differentiatorKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 16Workshops set their filter prices by looking at neighbourhood retail pricesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 17Owners of mid-range, Asian and locally built cars move to independent workshops once the warranty ends, while European-car owners tend to stay with dealer workshopsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 18Consumers are moving from do-it-yourself to do-it-for-me servicingKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand
- 19Electric Vehicle Council State of EVs 2025: EVs account for only 2% of all cars on Australian roads, with more than 410,000 EVs as of September 2025Public source · Electric Vehicle Council, 14 Oct 2025 · link
- 20Australia's Right to Repair law, in effect since 1 July 2022, boosts turnover by $2.4 billion (6.7%) and reduces inaccessible repairs by 40%, according to results of a government review announced by the AAAAPublic source · S&P Global Aftermarket Insight, 18 Mar 2026 · link
- 21Distributors expect brand owners to fund flyers, catalogues and technical selling points for their counter staffKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Australia and New Zealand