Who buys outsourced staff in Indonesia, what the fee really covers and how the new 6-category list changes the trade
Summary
- The new ministry regulation limits outsourcing to 6 auxiliary services and requires every agreement to be registered within 3 business days; the term 'operational support services' is left undefined, so the grey zone decides which roles survive. 1
- Providers' bread and butter has been call-centre, collection, admin, driver and technician roles for banks, telecoms, energy and factories; ABADI says banking, manufacturing and logistics absorb the most outsourced labour and claims 490,000 of 750,000 registered workers would not be absorbed under a restriction. 2 3
- An outsourced head is priced cost-plus: the statutory costs are passed through and a margin sits on top; vendors quote management fees of 10-15% and 8-18% of total labour cost, in their own words. 4 5 6
- The employer pays 3.7% JHT, 2% JP (to a wage cap of Rp 10,547,000), 0.3% JKM, a JKK rate of 0.24% to 1.74% by risk class, and 4% of the 5% BPJS Kesehatan contribution. 7 8
- THR must be paid 7 days before Lebaran, and the Jakarta provincial minimum wage rose 6.17% to Rp5,729,876, so a quote that leaves out holiday-allowance and severance provisions is incomplete, not cheap. 9 10 6
- Providers win on the order, not the worker, and the user company must now check that its provider meets its obligations; the labour backdrop is soft, with 63,789 layoffs reported through the JKP system from January to September 2026. 11 1 12
Transcript
016 kinds of work, and one grey zone
The rules on outsourcing have just changed. What do you tell a foreign investor first?
That the free-for-all is over. After the Job Creation Law there was no explicit list of what could be outsourced, and supplying workers was not clearly separated from contracting out a job. Then the Constitutional Court told the Minister to define the work, and Regulation 7/2026 now limits outsourcing to 6 auxiliary services: cleaning, food and beverage, security, drivers and transport for workers, "operational support services", and supporting services in mining, oil, gas and power. 1
My own order book was never mostly cleaning and catering. It was call-centre agents, collectors, admin clerks, drivers and technicians for banks, telecoms, energy and factories. 2 Drivers fit the list, and so does support in oil and gas. For the rest, everything depends on how "operational support services" will be read, and the regulation does not define it. 1
How many people sit in the exposed part?
The outsourcing association, ABADI, did a survey after the regulation came out. Of 750,000 workers registered as outsourced, it says 490,000 would not be absorbed if outsourcing were restricted, and it says banking, manufacturing and logistics take the most outsourced labour. Treat that as the association's own number from a body with an interest; I have not seen the method. 3
What I can tell you is that nobody is relaxed. A worker federation says the "operational support" wording could be a loophole that widens what is outsourced, while the employers' association says helpers, IT support, logistics, maintenance and project administration are fluctuating, project-based or need special skills. 13 So the same phrase worries one side as too open and is a practical question for the other. 13
02How an outsourced head is priced
Walk me through the monthly invoice for one outsourced worker.
It is cost-plus. Wage first, then the statutory costs, then provisions, then our fee. In staff dispatch generally the statutory contributions are passed through to the client and the margin is charged on the total employment cost, not buried inside the salary. 4
On the fee itself, I can only point at what vendors say publicly. One vendor says management fees are often 10-15% of total labour cost and vary with the service and the deal. Another says generally 8-18%, covering recruitment, payroll, BPJS administration and supervision. Both are vendors describing their own market, not a survey, and I would not quote either to a board as the market rate. 5 6
Does the fee differ by how you source the worker?
Yes, and outsiders mix this up. If we recruit the person and put them on our payroll, the margin is higher. If the client already found the person and we only run payroll, the margin is lower. 14 So when a client shows me a competitor's percentage, my first question is which of the two models it is quoting. The same percentage means different things. 14
Behind the difference is who carries the risk. In recruit-and-payroll we pay for sourcing, screening and the idle days between one worker leaving and the next starting. In payroll-only we are closer to an administrator, and the client keeps the hiring risk, so it is fair that the margin is lower. 14
Which statutory costs does the provider carry?
On the employment side the company pays 3.7% of wage for old-age savings (JHT) and 2% for pension (JP), and JP counts wages only up to Rp 10,547,000 a month. Accident cover (JKK) is wholly the company's, from 0.24% for office staff to 1.74% for construction and mining, depending on risk class, and death cover (JKM) is 0.3%. Check the risk class: a technician and an admin clerk do not carry the same JKK rate. 7
Health insurance, BPJS Kesehatan, is 5% of wage, of which 4% is the company's and 1% the employee's. 8 One vendor puts the company's total BPJS portion at about 10-11% of base wage. 6
03The costs that surprise a new buyer
Where do foreign clients get surprised?
THR, the religious holiday allowance. This year the Minister's circular required it to be paid 7 days before Lebaran, and the Minister said sanctions would follow for firms that did not. 9 The classic mistake is to price THR as a one-off in the quarter it falls due. One vendor spreads it at 1/12 per month, and says it also keeps a severance reserve of 5-8% of wage, depending on its own policy. When a quote has neither line, it is not cheaper, it is incomplete. 6
And the wage floor? Does it move every year?
Every year, and the provincial figure is only the start. Jakarta's provincial minimum for this year is Rp5,729,876, up 6.17%. 10 I cannot give you every district figure for a client with sites in several places, so a multi-site quote has to be built site by site, not from one national number. 10
My rule of thumb for the sales team: never send a multi-site price list before we have the full site list. The minimum wage is the one input the client can look up on its own and will check against our quote, so it has to be right before anything else is. 10
So where does the provider's real margin sit?
I can't open my books for you, and every client contract is different. But the structure is that the pass-through lines are not where we earn; the fee on top is, and the fee only holds if the replacement and rejection terms do not eat it. 4 Contracts let the client reject a worker in the first hours at no charge, and we must replace at no cost until the substitute starts. A bad month of replacements can erase a good fee. 15
04Who buys, and how orders arrive
Who are the buyers today?
By labour volume, the association names banking, manufacturing and logistics. 3 From my side, the old core has been banks, telecoms, energy and factories. 2 Foreign multinationals are the ones who buy senior executive search, while local companies lean more on dispatch and low-end outsourcing. That shapes who we talk to: a foreign firm's regional HR office is not the same buyer as a local conglomerate's operations head. 16
I would be careful about turning that into a rule. It depends on the customer, and a foreign bank with a large call centre can behave like a local manufacturer when it comes to volume dispatch. What is true is that the regional HR office buys on process and compliance, and the local operations head buys on speed and on whether the workers turn up on Monday. 16
Do large groups keep outsourcing in-house?
Some groups have their own outsourcing arm. A business process outsourcing company inside the Garuda Indonesia Group, for example, said in a January press release that its outsourced staff are the deciding element of its service quality. That is the company's own statement. 17 An in-group arm competes with us on trust and access, not on price, and it has to follow the same regulation as everybody else. 1
For us the real question is whether a group with its own arm sends the overflow outside. I cannot say how often it does, and it is not a number I can show you, which is why we put our effort into winning the order. 11
How does a provider win an order?
We spend more effort getting the order than finding the worker. 11 Finding people is the easier part, because past candidates' referrals supply a large share of candidates in Indonesia, and we aim to fill within a matter of weeks. 18 Where candidates are weak on basics, training becomes part of the offer, not an extra. 19
What is new is the buyer's side of the table. The user company must now ensure that the outsourcing company meets its obligations on wages, overtime, social security and holiday allowance. 1 Clients who used to ask only for the price will, I expect, start asking for proof of BPJS payments. I welcome it, because it favours providers who pay properly, and it gives my sales team something concrete to say when a cheaper competitor is cutting corners on contributions. 1
What is the hardest part of keeping an order once you have it?
The first days. A client can reject a worker in the first hours at no charge, and we have to replace the person at no cost until a substitute starts. 15 So a provider that sent the wrong person pays twice, once for the failed placement and again for the new one, and the client remembers. Good screening and a little training before day one are cheaper than a replacement. 19
05Contracts, registration and the transition
What changes in the paperwork?
The agreement must now state the work, the term, the location, the number of workers and their rights: wages, overtime, working hours, annual leave, safety, social security, holiday allowance and rights at termination. 1 And we must register each agreement with the local manpower office within 3 business days after signing. The office checks the scope and may refuse a receipt if the work is not a permitted kind. In practice that means the scope sentence in the agreement is no longer boilerplate: I now write it with the client's HR and legal people in the room, because a vague line is exactly what a reviewer will question. 1
Is that a formality?
I would not treat it as one. A lawyer's note describes the registration as a substantive review, not only a filing, and says unregistered or non-permitted outsourcing can bring sanctions that range from a warning up to loss of the business licence. For a small provider that is not an abstract risk, because a single refused registration on a large client can hold up the start of a whole site. 1 How strictly each local office applies it, I cannot tell you; it will differ from office to office until practice settles. I tell clients the same thing every week: do not assume the neighbouring office will read it the way ours does. 1
So my compliance checklist before signing anything: is the work one of the permitted kinds, does the agreement list every mandatory right, and will we register within the deadline. If the answer to the first one is "it depends how the office reads it", I tell the client before we sign, not after. 1
What happens to the contracts you already have?
Providers doing work outside the permitted kinds have a transition until 30 April 2028, and existing agreements run to their expiry. 1 That is breathing space, not a reprieve, because every new agreement I sign from now on is already under the new test and I cannot wait for the transition to run out before I change my model. I am using it to move clients with grey-zone roles onto contracts that look like a real service, with supervision and a result, not only bodies on a site. 1
Which of your roles would you move first?
The ones that look least like a service: the admin clerk and the call-centre or collection agent placed inside a client's own team and supervised by the client's own manager. 2 Those are the roles where a regulator is most likely to ask whether this is a service or only a supply of manpower, a distinction the lawyers say is still not clear. 1 Drivers and security, I am much less worried about, because they are named on the list and nobody has to argue about the reading. For the others I would rather tell the client early that the contract may need to change shape than discover it at registration. 1
Why do clients not just hire the people directly?
Because of fixed-term rules. If workers are employed directly by the user company, they could acquire permanent status, since fixed-term employment is restricted. 1 When a client does want to convert one of our people, the conversion fee is a negotiation. In Singapore, as I hear it, the fee falls the longer the worker has been on assignment, and I would expect Indonesian clients to ask for the same logic. Clients like the idea of buying out a good person after months of work, but they forget that we trained and screened that person, and that the fee is how we get paid for it. 20
What I would not do is promise a conversion price in the first meeting. The worker's time on site, how much training we put in and whether the client found the person itself all change the answer. 14
06Demand swings and the labour market
How is demand behaving this year?
The pattern is the one I know from every soft patch: when headcount is frozen, clients move from permanent hiring to contract staff, and use search only for senior or hard-to-fill roles. It reverses on recovery. 21 The Ministry has recorded 63,789 workers reporting layoffs through the job-loss guarantee system from January to September 2026. That is a reported figure, so I treat it as a floor, not a count of everyone affected, and it will miss people who never report. 12
For us, a layoff wave cuts both ways. Clients that freeze permanent hiring call us for contract staff, but clients that are cutting costs also squeeze the fee and ask whether a worker can be moved to another site. I would rather hold a contract with a tight replacement clause than chase a cheap new one. 21
Is the outsourced workforce big against the whole labour market?
I do not have a clean national count of outsourced workers, and the association's 750,000 is a registered figure. 3 For perspective, the statistics office puts the employed at 146.54 million, of whom 57.80% were informal in August 2025 and wage employees were 38.74%. 22 So the formal, payrolled worker is a minority, and that is exactly what the association is worried about: formal outsourced jobs sliding into the informal economy. 3
I cannot tell you how many of them would really move. The association says the risk is layoffs or a shift to informal work for people who cannot be absorbed, and unions see it differently. I would watch the registration data from the local manpower offices, if it ever becomes public, because that will show the real size of the permitted market. 3
Does your business live off one sector?
It cannot. Providers survive downturns by not depending on one sector and by taking lower-margin contract staffing when permanent hiring stops. 23 With the new list, I expect more providers to spread across cleaning, security and drivers, which are the safest categories, while the roles in the grey zone are held on shorter contracts. 1
Diversifying also protects the payroll team. A provider with one sector on its books has one pay day risk, one client's calendar and one bad quarter. Spreading across clients and sectors is how we survive the quarters when one of them freezes. 23
07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me
A Japanese or Korean staffing group wants in. How should it start?
Start with the services the regulation clearly names, and be honest about which of your planned roles sit in the grey zone. 1 Foreign entrants typically begin with contract staffing and build search capacity for the recovery, because search buyers in Indonesia are mostly foreign multinationals who already know the global brands. 16
Price the whole stack. Show the statutory lines, the holiday-allowance and severance provisions, and the fee separately. 6 Clients are now responsible for checking their provider, so a transparent invoice is a sales tool, not a cost. 1 And do not copy a percentage from a vendor's website; ask which model, recruit-and-payroll or payroll-only, it describes. 14
What would change your mind about the outlook, and what worries you?
A clear definition of "operational support services" would change my mind quickly, in either direction. Until it exists, interpretation depends on local offices and on how courts treat non-compliant agreements. 1 What worries me is the next step: unions are pressing to remove outsourcing from the draft manpower protection bill altogether, and the outsourcing association opposes it, warning of layoffs and a shift to informal work. 3
If the bill goes that way, the transition date is no longer the real deadline. I would rather be a provider with clean registrations, correct BPJS filings and a supervised-service contract model on that day than one who bet the grey zone would stay open. I can't tell you which way it goes, and anybody who says they can is selling something. 1
Sources and basis
- 1Ministry of Manpower Regulation No. 7 of 2026 on Outsourcing (MOM Reg. 7/2026), implementing Law No. 6 of 2023 (Job Creation) and Constitutional Court Decision No. 168/PUU-XXI/2023: outsourcing is limited to 6 auxiliary services (cleaning; food and beverage; security; drivers and transport for workers; operational support services; supporting services in mining, oil, gas and electric power), with the last two terms not defined; the agreement must state the work, term, location, number of workers and the workers' rights (wages, overtime, working hours, annual leave, OHS, social security, religious holiday allowance, rights at termination); the outsourcing company must register the agreement with the local manpower office within 3 business days after signing, and the office may refuse a receipt if the scope is not permitted; the user company must ensure the outsourcing company meets its obligations; non-compliant existing providers have a transition until 30 April 2028; workers employed directly by a user company could acquire permanent status because fixed-term employment is restrictedPublic source · Makarim & Taira S. (law firm), M&T Advisory Issue 21, May 2026 · link
- 2Indonesian dispatch has been concentrated in banking, oil and gas, telecom and manufacturing, for roles such as call centre, collection, drivers, admin and techniciansKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta staff dispatch firms
- 3The chair of the Asosiasi Bisnis Alih Daya Indonesia (ABADI), speaking on 30 Sep 2026, opposed unions' demand to remove outsourcing entirely from the draft Manpower Protection bill; she said banking, manufacturing and logistics absorb the most outsourced labour, that workers who could not be absorbed might be laid off or shift from formal to informal work, and that in a survey by her team, done after Regulation 7/2026 was signed on 30 April 2026, of 750,000 workers registered as outsourced, 490,000 would not be absorbed if outsourcing were restricted (the association's own survey)Public source · Kompas.com, 1 Oct 2026 · link
- 4In staff dispatch generally, the statutory contributions are passed through to the client and the provider's fee is a margin charged on the total employment costKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, staff dispatch firms in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia
- 5An outsourcing vendor's website says management fees from outsourcing vendors are often in the range of 10-15% of total labour cost, varying with the services and the agreement (the vendor's own statement)Public source · KSPS (outsourcing/BPO vendor) website, accessed Oct 2026 (page updated 2026) · link
- 6An outsourcing vendor's website lists cost of labour components: the company's BPJS portion about 10-11% of base wage; THR provisioned at 1/12 per month; a severance reserve under Government Regulation 35/2021, usually 5-8% of wage depending on vendor policy; and a vendor management fee generally 8-18% of total cost of labour, covering recruitment, payroll, BPJS administration and supervision (the vendor's own statement)Public source · Sigma Solusi Servis (outsourcing vendor) website, accessed Oct 2026 (page updated 2026) · link
- 7Employer-side BPJS Ketenagakerjaan contributions for wage earners: JHT old-age 3.7% of wage borne by the company (employee 2%); JKK work accident borne wholly by the company at 0.24% to 1.74% of wage depending on risk class (0.24% office staff, 0.54% cleaners and cashiers, 0.89% technicians, 1.27% factory workers, 1.74% construction and mining); JKM death 0.3% of wage, wholly the company's; JP pension 2% borne by the company (employee 1%), with a wage cap for JP of Rp 10,547,000 a monthPublic source · BPJS Ketenagakerjaan, article on JHT, JKK, JKM, JP and JKP contributions, accessed Oct 2026 (page updated 2025) · link
- 8BPJS Kesehatan contribution for private-sector employees is 5% of wage, of which 4% is borne by the company and 1% by the employee (HR-software company's explainer)Public source · DataOn (HR software firm) explainer, accessed Oct 2026 · link
- 9Under Minister of Manpower circular No. M/3/HK.04.00/III/2026, the religious holiday allowance (THR) must be paid 7 days before Idulfitri 2026; the Minister said sanctions would be imposed on companies that break the rulePublic source · Bisnis.com, 14 Mar 2026 · link
- 10The DKI Jakarta provincial minimum wage (UMP) for 2026 was set at Rp5,729,876, up 6.17% (Rp333,115), after agreement in the provincial wage councilPublic source · Beritajakarta.id (Jakarta provincial government news), 24 Dec 2025 · link
- 11Dispatch providers spend more effort winning the order from the client than finding the workerKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta staff dispatch firms
- 12The Ministry of Manpower recorded 63,789 workers who reported being laid off (PHK) in the Job Loss Guarantee (JKP) system from January to September 2026Public source · CNN Indonesia, 11 Oct 2026 · link
- 13Reporting by Kompas on 5 May 2026: Regulation 7/2026 limits outsourcing to 6 areas, one of which is 'operational support services'; the secretary-general of the worker federation OPSI said that wording could be a loophole to widen what is outsourced; the employers' association Apindo said many support functions (helper, IT support, logistics, maintenance, project administration) are fluctuating, project-based or need special skillsPublic source · Kompas.com, 5 May 2026 · link
- 14Two dispatch models coexist: recruit-and-payroll, which earns a higher margin, and payroll-only for workers the client found itself, which earns a lower marginKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta staff dispatch firms
- 15Dispatch contracts let the client reject a worker in the first hours at no charge, and require the provider to replace a worker at no cost until a substitute startsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta staff dispatch firms
- 16In Indonesia, foreign multinationals are the main buyers of senior executive search, while local companies rely more on staff dispatch and low-end outsourcing; foreign entrants typically start with contract staffing in a downturn and build search capacity for the recoveryKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta recruitment and dispatch firms
- 17PT Garuda Daya Pratama Sejahtera (GDPS), a business process outsourcing provider within the Garuda Indonesia Group, said in a press release on 13 Jan 2026 that its outsourced workers are the deciding element of service quality in competence-based BPO (the company's own statement)Public source · Kompas.com, 13 Jan 2026 (company press release) · link
- 18Providers aim to fill a client request within a matter of weeks, and past candidates' referrals supply a large share of candidates in IndonesiaKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Jakarta recruitment and dispatch firms
- 19Education levels among many candidates are low, so training is part of what a dispatch provider offers the clientKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, staff dispatch firms in Malaysia and Indonesia
- 20In Singapore, dispatch conversion fees for turning a contract worker into a permanent employee fall the longer the worker has been on assignmentKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Singapore staff dispatch firms
- 21When headcount is frozen, clients shift from permanent hiring to contract staff and use search only for senior or hard-to-fill roles; the swing reverses on recoveryKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, recruitment firms in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia
- 22BPS August 2025 labour force, reported by DDTCNews: 146.54 million people employed; the informal share was 57.80% of those employed, down slightly from 57.95% in August 2024; wage employees (buruh/karyawan/pegawai) were 38.74% of those employedPublic source · DDTCNews, reporting BPS August 2025 labour-force data, accessed Oct 2026 · link
- 23Dispatch providers diversify away from dependence on one sector, and into lower-margin contract staffing, to survive downturnsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, recruitment firms in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia