Distribution & channels · Expert interview

Why Indonesian supplement networks sell through stockists and shake clubs, and what the marketplace ban changes

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Indonesia
Industry
Food supplements
Length
≈ 30 min read
WFDSAAP2LIAPLIMinistry of TradeBPOMBPJPHDSN-MUIHerbalifeHalal Network International (HNI)Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with managers and senior distributors of direct-selling nutrition companies, drugstore and specialist health-store staff, and importers in Jakarta, Medan and Surabaya, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts; every figure comes from a 2024-2026 public source, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • Direct selling in Indonesia is mostly a health business: wellness was 68% of direct sellers' 2024 retail sales, and 8,331,000 people were active in direct selling, 73% of them women. 1
  • Product moves through uplines, member stockists and neighbourhood shake clubs, and sells on testimonials among friends and relatives rather than shelf visibility. 2 3 4 5
  • Consumables sold at a modest mark-up over distributor price keep a member alive; the repeat order, not the first sale, is the business. 6 7
  • PP No. 3 of 2026 lists the signs of a pyramid scheme and keeps network products off indirect channels; the Ministry of Trade says MLM products may not be sold on e-commerce. 8 9
  • The market is shrinking and the rules are tightening: Indonesia's direct selling sales were USD 1,092 million in 2024, a change of -11.3%, and BPOM found 15,949 marketplace links for illegal or non-compliant health supplements in 2025. 1 10
  • Halal is a selling point on Java, and the mandatory halal deadline for health supplements has moved from 17 October 2026 to 17 October 2028. 11

Transcript

01The testimonial is the shop

KAKIRA Analyst

You lead a big team selling nutrition products across East Java. What should an outsider understand first about how supplements are sold here?

EXExpert

That direct selling in this country is mostly a health business. The federation's own figures put wellness at 68% of what direct sellers sold in Indonesia in 2024, against 16% for cosmetics and personal care, and they count 8,331,000 people active in direct selling, 73% of them women. 1

And the product does not sell from a shelf. It sells because my neighbour lost weight and showed her sister, and her sister asked where she got the shake. People buy because a friend shows them the result. The testimonial does the selling, first among family and friends, then at the arisan, the women's savings gathering, and after the Koran study group. 4 That is why supplements fit us so well. The customer needs somebody to explain, to follow up, to ask after a few weeks how she feels. A shelf in a drugstore cannot do that. 5

KAKIRA Analyst

And this year the rules changed under your feet?

EXExpert

Since January, yes. The new government regulation, number 3 of 2026, came in on 15 January 2026, and it says a direct-selling company may not sell the goods in its licence through indirect distribution channels. 8 Then in February the Director General of Domestic Trade said it plainly: MLM products may not be sold on e-commerce, because the way we sell is not online retail. 9

He also said the party that gets hurt by marketplace selling is the MLM company itself, and from the ground I agree. 9 A customer who can buy the same shake cheaper on an app does not need me, and the modest mark-up over distributor price is all a member earns on a sale. 6 So for the people who do the real work, the visits, the measuring, the follow-up call, this rule was good news. 4

02How a member joins and what she earns

KAKIRA Analyst

Walk me through how somebody joins your network.

EXExpert

She joins through an upline, the person who sponsors her, usually the friend who sold her the product in the first place. She pays a one-off fee for the starter kit and a yearly renewal, and from then on she buys at distributor price. 12 Most of my new members start as customers. They liked the result, they buy for the family anyway, and then they think, why not for my neighbours too. 4

The law now draws the line very clearly. The regulation lists the signs of a pyramid scheme: profit made from membership or registration fees, several memberships under the same name and identity, commissions or bonuses paid out of membership fees or recruitment, and bonuses from a marketing plan that are not based on selling goods. 8 So I tell my leaders: the starter kit must be a kit, not a ticket. If your income comes from people joining and not from product being drunk, you are on the wrong side. 12

KAKIRA Analyst

What does a member actually make on a sale?

EXExpert

I cannot give you the numbers for my plan, and it depends on the rank and on the product. What I can tell you is the shape. A member sells to her customer at a modest mark-up over what she paid as a distributor. 6 That margin is small, so nobody gets rich on one sale. What pays is the customer who orders again every month: the shake for breakfast, the slimming tea, the tablets. 7

The mistake outsiders make is to bring us a beautiful product that a customer buys once. A cream for a special occasion, a device, a one-time cure. My people cannot live on that. Give me something the customer finishes and needs again, and the network does the rest. 7

03What sells, and why halal comes first on Java

KAKIRA Analyst

Which products move best through your network?

EXExpert

Consumables, always. Meal-replacement shakes, slimming tea, algae tablets, bee products, fruit juices. Things that run out and bring the customer back. 7 In my team the shake is the door. Once a family trusts the shake, the mother asks about something for her joints and the son asks about protein. 4

On Java the first question about a new product is often not the price, it is whether it is halal. You see it in what the companies themselves announce. Herbalife says it received a sharia certificate for multi-level direct selling from DSN-MUI, which looked at its marketing model, product compliance, halal certification from BPJPH and its membership of APLI. 13 And HNI, a local halal network founded in 2012, was reported last year to have 5 million partners, more than 200,000 Halal Mart outlets and 150 categories of halal products. 14

KAKIRA Analyst

So a foreign brand without the halal logo starts behind?

EXExpert

In my area, yes, even before anybody reads the label. The law gives them more time than they thought. The halal phase for health supplements was meant to end on 17 October 2026, and on 16 October 2026 the government announced it moves to 17 October 2028 for health supplements, cosmetics and other categories. 15 11 But my customers do not wait for the deadline. At the Koran study group the halal question comes before the price question, whatever the law says. 4

04Stockists, branches and the shake club

KAKIRA Analyst

How does product physically reach a customer outside Jakarta?

EXExpert

The big networks run regional branches, and under them members operate their own distribution centres and stockists, stokis we call them, where the team comes to pick up product. 2 I run one in Surabaya. On a busy day my front room looks like a small warehouse, and the members come by motorbike after the school run to collect for their customers. 2

Look at how a big company describes its own network. Herbalife says it has 36 distribution centers across the country, and that its new Medan centre offers nutrition consultations, training programs and space for community, with a vending machine for buying products planned for 2026. 16 That tells you the branch is a training room as much as a stock room. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

And the shake club you mentioned?

EXExpert

In the weight-management networks a member opens a small health café in her neighbourhood, sometimes in the front of her house. People come in the morning for a shake, and every so often she measures them: weight, waist, the body numbers. 3 It looks like a little shop, but it is really the testimonial made visible. The neighbours see the same faces getting thinner every week, and they ask. 4

A newcomer should understand that the café is owned by the member, not by the company. She pays for it, she runs it, and if the product stops working for her customers she closes it. 3

KAKIRA Analyst

How different is selling in a city like Medan, or a smaller town, from Jakarta?

EXExpert

The smaller cities follow Jakarta, but later, and many buyers there still find health products expensive. 17 In Medan the better-off families spread a product by word of mouth very fast, and young men buy protein to build muscle. 17 But the truly premium buyer is thin everywhere outside Jakarta and a few big cities. 18 So in the smaller towns I lead with the cheaper everyday products and leave the premium line for the members who already have customers who trust them. 7

05Against the drugstore and the marketplace

KAKIRA Analyst

How do you compete with the drugstore chains?

EXExpert

We do not compete on the shelf. Most supplements here are imported and sold as capsules and tablets through the chain drugstores, independent pharmacies and specialist chains, and the high-end imported brands come to the chains through exclusive importers. 19 The good drugstores in the malls do something close to what we do: the staff explain the product face to face and get people to try it. 20

Their strength is the discount. A small price cut moves supplements noticeably, even with richer customers. 21 My strength is that I am there next month, and the month after. Education and trust matter more for a supplement than being seen on a shelf. 5

KAKIRA Analyst

What about the online marketplaces? Even before the ban, people sold there.

EXExpert

That is my biggest headache. BPOM says its online patrols in 2025 found 197,725 marketplace links selling illegal or non-compliant drugs and food, and 15,949 of them were health supplements. 10 When a customer buys a fake with our brand's photo on an app and it does nothing, or makes her sick, she does not blame the app. The bad name lands on every direct seller, the same way the bad schemes have always hurt the honest ones. 22

So for me the new rule is part of the answer. It keeps the network products off the marketplace. 9 The rest is my people telling customers, every time, buy from your member, not from a link. 4

06Registration, claims and the testimonial line

KAKIRA Analyst

What does a new brand need before your team can sell it?

EXExpert

Registration with BPOM, the food and drug agency, first. Nothing moves without it, and an experienced member will ask to see the registration number before she puts her name behind a product. 23 Then halal, as we said. Then a price that leaves room for the mark-up. 6

KAKIRA Analyst

Testimonials do the selling, you said. Where is the line on what a member can claim?

EXExpert

The line is the approved claim. In March 2025 BPOM revoked the marketing authorization of a health supplement that had been relabelled and advertised excessively beyond its approved claim, which was only to help maintain skin health. It ordered the product withdrawn and the advertisements removed from all media. 24

So I train my people this way. Tell what happened to you, honestly. Do not say it cures anything, and do not promise your customer what happened to you will happen to her. The testimonial is still the most powerful thing we have, but it has to stay a friend's story, not a medical claim. 4

07A shrinking market with stricter rules

KAKIRA Analyst

Is the business still growing?

EXExpert

Not in total. The federation counts Indonesia's direct selling at USD 1,092 million in 2024, a change of -11.3% on 2023, and over 2021-2024 the market shrank by 7.3% a year. It is still the last billion-dollar market in the Asia/Pacific region. 1 On the ground I feel it as fewer new members staying past their first renewal. 12

At the same time there are many companies. At the association's award this year, 167 direct-selling companies presented their results, and the Director General said Indonesia is one of the countries with strict rules for multi-level business. 25 The regulation also says a company may not use a virtual office or shared space as its address, which will clear out some of the fly-by-night operators. 8 I think that is healthy. The bad image of a few schemes still costs all of us. 22

08Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

A Japanese or Korean supplement company wants to sell through direct selling here. What should it do?

EXExpert

Register with BPOM before anything else, and get halal certification even though the deadline has moved, because my customers ask now. 23 11 Bring consumables that people finish and reorder, not a one-time product. 7 Keep the starter kit cheap and real, so nobody can say your income comes from joining fees. 8

Then build the stockists outside Jakarta early, with members who already have customers, and accept that the smaller cities will be slower and more price-conscious. 2 17 And do not put the product on a marketplace to move stock. The ministry has said MLM products may not be sold there, and your own members will stop trusting you the day they find your product cheaper on an app. 9 6

KAKIRA Analyst

What would change your mind about this model, and what worries you?

EXExpert

What would change my mind is if customers stopped needing a person to explain. Herbalife plans a vending machine for its products in 2026. 16 If machines and apps can give the trust a member gives, the stockist in my front room is in trouble. I do not think we are there. A supplement still needs a friend who says, look at me. 5

What worries me is the image. The sales are already shrinking, and every fake on a marketplace and every scheme that lives on joining fees makes the honest member's next visit harder. 1 10 22

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    WFDSA global direct selling 2024 retail sales report (figures based only on DSA member companies): Indonesia 2024 retail sales of USD 1,092 million, a change of -11.3% on 2023, with a 2021-2024 CAGR of -7.3%; 8,331,000 individuals active in direct selling, 73% of them women; wellness products were 68% of Indonesia's 2024 direct selling retail sales and cosmetics and personal care 16%; Indonesia is the last billion-dollar market in the Asia/Pacific region and the eighth largest there, with 1.7% of regional sales
    Public source · WFDSA, Global Direct Selling 2024 Retail Sales (STATS report 2024-2025), Dec 2025 · link
  2. 2
    Large networks run regional branches plus member-operated distribution centres and stockists where members pick up product
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  3. 3
    Weight-management networks run member-owned neighbourhood health cafés that sell shakes and offer periodic body measurement
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  4. 4
    Selling relies on personal contact and testimonials of results among friends and relatives; people buy because a friend shows them the result, and the testimonial does the selling
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  5. 5
    Testimonial-driven direct selling suits supplements because education and trust matter more than shelf visibility
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  6. 6
    Members sell to end customers at a modest mark-up over distributor price
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  7. 7
    The best sellers are consumables such as algae tablets, meal-replacement shakes, fruit juices, bee products and slimming tea, which drive repeat orders
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  8. 8
    Government Regulation (PP) No. 3 of 2026, signed and promulgated on 15 January 2026, amends the 2021 regulation on trade: it defines a pyramid scheme as a business not based on selling goods; its signs include drawing profit from membership or registration fees, accepting several memberships under the same name and identity, paying commissions or bonuses out of membership fees or the recruitment of direct sellers, and paying commissions or bonuses from a marketing plan not based on sales of goods; a direct-selling company may not sell the goods in its licence through indirect distribution channels, may not use a virtual office or shared space as its business address, and services may not be marketed through direct selling
    Public source · PP No. 3 of 2026, text via pasal.id, Jan 2026 · link
  9. 9
    The Ministry of Trade's Director General of Domestic Trade said MLM products may not be sold on e-commerce because their selling mechanism is not online retail; the ban is set out in PP No. 3 of 2026; he said the ban protects the direct-selling ecosystem and that the party harmed by such selling is the MLM company itself
    Public source · EmitenNews, 5 Feb 2026 · link
  10. 10
    In its 2025 online patrols BPOM found 197,725 marketplace links selling illegal or non-compliant drugs and food, of which 15,949 were health supplements, 73,722 cosmetics, 35,984 drugs and 32,684 processed food
    Public source · BPOM press release, 4 Mar 2026 · link
  11. 11
    The Indonesian government announced at an online session on 16 October 2026 that the mandatory halal certification deadline of 17 October 2026 moves to 17 October 2028 for traditional medicines, quasi-medicinal products, health supplements, cosmetics and other categories, through an amendment to PP 42/2024; further provisions are to follow in official regulations
    Public source · ChemLinked, 19 Oct 2026 · link
  12. 12
    Members join through an up-line sponsor, pay a one-off starter-kit fee and a yearly renewal fee, and then buy at distributor price
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  13. 13
    Herbalife Indonesia received sharia certification for multi-level direct selling from the National Sharia Council of the Indonesian Ulema Council (DSN-MUI), which assessed its business and marketing model, product compliance, halal certification from BPJPH and proof of APLI membership; the company says it markets over 30 nutrition and health products through distributors who give one-on-one coaching (the company's own statement)
    Public source · Herbalife Indonesia press release, 27 Mar 2025 · link
  14. 14
    At its 13th anniversary, Halal Network International (HNI), founded in 2012, was reported to have 5 million partners (mitra), more than 200,000 Halal Mart outlets and 150 categories of halal products made by Indonesian businesses
    Public source · Republika, 22 Sep 2025 · link
  15. 15
    Under PP 42 of 2024, the phase of mandatory halal certification for natural medicines, quasi drugs and health supplements runs from 17 October 2021 to 17 October 2026
    Public source · BPJPH news, Jul 2025 · link
  16. 16
    Herbalife moved its Medan sales center to a new site offering nutrition consultations, training programs and spaces for community interaction; the company says it operates 36 distribution centers nationwide, has been in Indonesia for 27 years and plans an automated sales center, a vending machine for buying products, in 2026 (the company's own statement)
    Public source · Herbalife Indonesia press release, 13 Oct 2025 · link
  17. 17
    Secondary cities follow Jakarta trends with a lag and many buyers there still find health products expensive; in Medan affluent buyers spread a product's popularity by word of mouth, and young men buy protein products for muscle building
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  18. 18
    Premium health products depend on a thin affluent base concentrated in Jakarta and a few other large cities
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  19. 19
    Supplements are mostly imported and sold in capsules and tablets through chain drugstores, independent pharmacies, specialist chains and direct-selling networks; exclusive importer-distributors supply the drugstore chains with high-end imported brands
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  20. 20
    Mall-based drugstores educate middle and upper-income customers face to face and drive trial
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  21. 21
    A small discount noticeably lifts supplement sales, even among upper-income buyers
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  22. 22
    The negative image of some multi-level schemes rubs off on all direct sellers
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  23. 23
    Product registration with the food and drug agency is the gatekeeper for any new supplement
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Indonesia
  24. 24
    In March 2025 BPOM revoked the marketing authorization of a health supplement that had been relabelled with a sticker naming an ingredient it did not contain and advertised excessively beyond its approved claim of helping to maintain skin health; BPOM said this could mislead the public, issued a strict warning, ordered the product withdrawn and its advertisements removed from all media, and halted its distribution
    Public source · BPOM public explanation, 11 Mar 2025 · link
  25. 25
    At the AP2LI direct-selling award held every two years since 2020, 167 direct-selling companies presented their performance; the Ministry of Trade's Director General of Domestic Trade said Indonesia is one of the countries applying strict rules to multi-level business
    Public source · ANTARA, 23 Feb 2026 · link

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Health foods and supplements in Indonesia