Customer voice · Expert interview

Why a Niigata Koshihikari grower keeps the old variety after the heat, and what price would make him switch

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Japan
Industry
Rice seed
Length
≈ 30 min read
JA Zen-NohJA Zen-Noh NiigataMitsui Chemicals Crop & Life SolutionsMinistry of Agriculture, Forestry and FisheriesNiigata PrefectureRice Stable Supply Support OrganizationNational Agriculture and Food Research Organization
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with rice farmers, co-operative and seed-distribution staff, public breeders and rice traders in Japan, with seed-trade interviews in other Asian rice markets, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts; every figure comes from a public source dated 2024-2026, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • Growers in brand-rice areas switch variety only when the rice price makes it pay; the seed price hardly enters the decision. 1 2
  • The heat hit Koshihikari hard: in Niigata its first-grade ratio fell to 4.7% in 2023 while Shin-no-suke kept 94.7%, yet Koshihikari still held 32.6% of the national planted area in the 2024 crop. 3 4
  • Heat-tolerant varieties reached 16.4% of table rice in 2024, but each new variety moves through the prefecture's recommended list and the co-operative's seed orders, and seed supply can take years. 5 6 7
  • The price signal flipped in a year: Niigata's advance payment for general Koshihikari fell 38% to 18,500 yen per 60 kg, against a national average cost of 15,814 yen per 60 kg for individual farms. 8 9
  • Private hybrids can win on yield, but Mitsuhikari seed sales ended in March 2025, and seed of a first-generation hybrid saved on the farm does not keep the same quality. 10 11
  • With core farmers averaging 67.7 years and JA Zen-Noh collecting only 26% of the 2024 crop, a newcomer needs taste first, labour saving second, and a buyer for the rice before the seed. 12 13 14 15

Transcript

01The summer that changed the conversation

KAKIRA Analyst

You grow mostly Koshihikari on the Niigata plain. What would actually make you switch to another variety?

EXExpert

The price my rice sells for. Everyone from outside asks me about the seed, its price, its yield, its disease package. The seed is the small line on my invoice. What decides is the price of the bag I sell in autumn. 2 In a famous rice area you do not switch unless the rice price makes it pay, and here the name Koshihikari has paid for a very long time. 1

What did shake us was the summer of 2023. The prefecture's own figures show Koshihikari at 4.7% first grade that year, ittō-mai we call it, the top inspection grade, against 25.0% in the bad year of 2019. Shin-no-suke, the prefecture's heat-tolerant variety, kept 94.7% in the same year. The main reason Koshihikari was downgraded was chalky grain. I sold most of my crop a grade down that year, and nobody had to explain the numbers to me. 3

KAKIRA Analyst

So after that summer, did farmers here switch?

EXExpert

Some added a block, very few switched. The prefecture pushed the heat-tolerant varieties for the 2024 crop, and Shin-no-suke went from about 4,500 ha to about 5,200 ha. 3 That is real growth, but next to how much Koshihikari we plant it is a corner of the map. Nationally, Koshihikari was still 32.6% of the planted area in the 2024 crop, down from the year before. 4

And the next summer gave Koshihikari back its pride: first grade at 73.4% in 2024 on the preliminary count, Shin-no-suke at 98.1%. 3 So a farmer who stayed with Koshihikari did not look foolish. Taste and the name still sell. A new variety has to clear the taste test first, then the price, and only then do we talk about yield. 14 1

02How seed reaches my paddy

KAKIRA Analyst

Walk me through how you buy seed. Where does it come from?

EXExpert

From the JA, the local co-operative. In winter the order sheet comes round with the varieties the prefecture recommends, shōreihinshu, and I tick what I want for the spring. I do not shop around and I have never thought much about the system behind the sheet. 16 I buy fresh seed almost every season. Saving your own seed looks cheap, but the grain drifts, the inspection grade suffers, and the buyer wants the variety to be what the bag says. 17

The calendar is early, which outsiders often miss. In Kanagawa, for example, the JA began taking orders in November 2025 for seed to sow in 2026. 18 If your variety is not on that sheet by then, you have lost a whole year. 6

KAKIRA Analyst

Who decides what goes on that sheet?

EXExpert

The prefecture and its extension office decide what is recommended and which farms grow the seed, and the co-operative distributes it. A new variety needs both behind it before it reaches farmers like me in any volume. 6 The breeders themselves I almost never see. I have heard researchers complain that the extension side decides which of their varieties farmers can get. 19

And it is slow. Kumamoto adopted Nijinokirameki, a heat-tolerant, high-yield variety, as a recommended variety last year, and the paper said seed for general cultivation could start as early as fiscal 2029. 7 So when a seed company tells me a variety is ready, I ask: ready for whom, and in which year will my JA have it? 6

03What a new variety has to prove

KAKIRA Analyst

Rank the things you weigh on a new variety: taste, yield, the price it fetches, labour.

EXExpert

Taste is the gate. If it fails the taste test nobody here will grow it, whatever the yield. 14 After the gate it is the price the rice fetches, because that is where the money is. 1 2 Labour comes next, and every year it climbs the list. My neighbours are part-time, and the old men who used to help at transplanting have stopped. Anything that saves a pass through the paddy, or lets me seed directly instead of raising seedlings, gets my attention. 15

Yield on its own comes last for a brand-area grower. More bags of a rice nobody asks for by name is not a plan. 20

KAKIRA Analyst

The prefecture has a new heat-tolerant line in trials. Does it interest you?

EXExpert

It does, with a question mark. Niigata 124 is described as heat-tolerant, slow to lodge and close to Koshihikari in taste, aimed at business use such as bento and rice balls, and at export. It is in field trials across the prefecture. 21 The taste claim is the right claim. The words business use tell me who the buyer is: not the shopper who pays for the Niigata name, but a kitchen that pays by the bag. 20

A breeder once admitted to our people that nobody knows exactly what makes a variety succeed: one said the price, another said the name. 22 From the paddy I would say both, and you need the name first. 20

KAKIRA Analyst

Across Japan, how far have heat-tolerant varieties got?

EXExpert

To 16.4% of table rice in 2024, on 206,000 ha, up 1.8 points in a year. 5 That is a steady climb, not a stampede. Most of it is farmers adding a field of the new one next to the old one, which is what I did. 1

04The price math this year

KAKIRA Analyst

You keep coming back to price. What does it look like this autumn?

EXExpert

Last year was a dream. The JA's first advance payment, the gaisan-kin, for Niigata Koshihikari was 30,000 yen per 60 kg, up 13,000 yen. 13 This August the figure for general Koshihikari, outside Uonuma, Sado and Iwafune, came in at 18,500 yen per 60 kg, 38% down, and the reason given was rising stocks. 8 Across Hokkaido and the Hokuriku-Shinetsu prefectures the payments are down about 20-40%, and farmers fear they will not cover costs. 23

Put that next to cost. The national average full cost for an individual farm was 15,814 yen per 60 kg for the 2024 crop, and 12,090 yen for an organised corporate farm. 9 A small family farm sits on a thin line this year. 9 8

KAKIRA Analyst

And beyond the JA, is the whole market falling?

EXExpert

It is heading that way. The national average traded price was 31,556 yen per 60 kg in August, down 930 yen from July. 24 Planned table-rice area for this year is 1,363,000 ha, and with a normal harvest output would be 7.33 million tonnes against an assumed maximum demand of 7.11 million tonnes. 25 In the supermarket the average fell below 3,500 yen per 5 kg in the first week of July. 26

KAKIRA Analyst

Does a high-yield variety look better when the price per bag falls?

EXExpert

On paper, yes. When each bag is worth less, more bags per field is tempting, and in rice seed farmers will pay a lot more for a seed that really lifts the margin. 10 But for me the extra bags only count if somebody has already agreed to buy that variety. Otherwise I have swapped a famous name for a pile of unnamed rice in a falling market. 1 20

05Private seed and the hybrid that vanished

KAKIRA Analyst

Have private companies' varieties ever tempted you?

EXExpert

The hybrids, yes, for business rice. Growers will pay many times the public seed price for private hybrid seed when the yield gain lifts their margin. 10 The best private offers came as a package: seed, an adviser in your field, and the company buying the rice back. That replaces what the JA used to do for us. 27

Then look at what happened to Mitsuhikari. The company did not produce seed in 2025 and ended seed sales at the end of March 2025. It is a first-generation hybrid, so seed you save on the farm does not keep the same quality. It applied to abolish the brand in all 19 prefectures where it was set, and one public comment asked for the variety to be passed to a third party. 11 That is the risk in one paragraph: with a hybrid, your next season depends on one company's decision. 11

KAKIRA Analyst

What about varieties bred with newer techniques, gene editing or biotechnology?

EXExpert

Honestly, most farmers I know could not explain the difference between the techniques. Knowledge at farm level is thin, and the shoppers are wary of anything that sounds modified, so the label decides it. 28 Retailers already print the variety, the fertiliser and how many times the crop was sprayed on their own-label packs. 29 A variety that cannot be named proudly on a pack has a hard road in Japan, whatever the yield. 28

06The co-op, the buyers and the people

KAKIRA Analyst

Besides seed, what does the co-operative do for you, and is that changing?

EXExpert

It collects my rice, pays the advance, sells me fertiliser and chemicals, and sends someone when the crop looks wrong. 30 But its grip is weaker. JA Zen-Noh's collection of the 2024 crop fell to 26%, it expected to miss its target of about 30% for the 2025 crop even after raising the advance payments, and more farmers now sell directly or to other buyers. 13 I sell part of mine to a private dealer myself. 30

That matters for a seed company. The JA is still the road for seed, but the person who pays for the rice is less and less often the JA. 6 13

KAKIRA Analyst

You mentioned labour. How tight is it?

EXExpert

Look at the national figures. Core farm workers were 1.036 million in 2025, less than half the 2.4 million of 2000, with an average age of 67.7, and 69.6% were 65 or over. 12 In the prefecture the big farms are expanding direct-seeded area and mixing early and late varieties to spread the work and the heat risk. 3 For an ageing village, a variety that fits that kind of farming beats a variety that adds a ton. 15

07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

A foreign seed or input company wants growers like you. What should it do?

EXExpert

Start with the prefecture and the co-operative, because without them your variety does not reach the order sheet. 6 Then plant demonstration fields in our area and let us walk them. Rice farmers across Asia adopt a variety only after they see it work nearby and at scale, and we are no different. 31 Taste first: if the cooked rice disappoints, nothing else you say will matter. 14

Bring a buyer with you. The packages that worked here were seed, advice and a buy-back together. 27 And sell me labour saving, direct seeding and fewer passes, not only yield. 15

KAKIRA Analyst

What would change your mind about Koshihikari, and what worries you?

EXExpert

A written contract price for a heat-tolerant variety that covers my cost in a bad year would move more of my fields than any brochure. 1 2 Another summer like 2023, when Koshihikari fell to 4.7% first grade, would move them too. 3

What worries me is getting both at once: heat that ruins the grade and a price that has already fallen 38% for general Koshihikari. 8 3 If the advance payments do not cover costs, the older farmers will not switch variety. They will stop farming, and then no seed company has a customer. 23 12

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    Farmers in famous brand-rice areas will not switch varieties unless the rice price makes it pay
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  2. 2
    Growers say the seed price is not really the issue; what the rice sells for is
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  3. 3
    Niigata first-grade ratios: Koshihikari 4.7% in 2023 against 25.0% in 2019 and 73.4% in 2024 (preliminary); Shin-no-suke 94.7% in 2023 and 98.1% in 2024; all non-glutinous rice 14.8% in 2023; the main cause of Koshihikari downgrades was chalky grain; for the 2024 crop the prefecture pushed more planting of existing heat-tolerant varieties (Shin-no-suke, Nijinokirameki and others), with Shin-no-suke at about 4,500 ha in 2023 and about 5,200 ha in 2024; large farms increased direct-seeded area; early and late varieties combined to spread risk
    Public source · Niigata Prefecture, agriculture department, climate adaptation seminar presentation, 21 Jan 2025 · link
  4. 4
    2024 crop non-glutinous rice (uruchi), excluding brewing and glutinous rice: Koshihikari was the most planted variety at 32.6% of the planted area (main areas Niigata, Ibaraki, Fukushima), followed by Hitomebore 8.4%, Hinohikari 7.1%, Akitakomachi 6.7% and Nanatsuboshi 3.4%; Koshihikari's share fell from the previous crop; the top 10 varieties made up 68.6% (69.6% the year before) and the top 20 made up 78.7%; Koshihikari Niigata BL is counted as Koshihikari
    Public source · Rice Stable Supply Support Organization, 2024-crop rice planting by variety, 3 Oct 2025 · link
  5. 5
    In 2024 the planted area of heat-tolerant rice varieties rose by 25,000 ha to 206,000 ha, and their share of table rice rose 1.8 points to 16.4%
    Public source · Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 2024 global warming impact survey report (press release), 26 Sep 2025 · link
  6. 6
    A new variety needs the prefecture's extension service and the co-operative to back it before it reaches farmers at scale; the extension side picks the seed farms and the co-operative distributes
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice seed chain
  7. 7
    Kumamoto Prefecture adopted Nijinokirameki as a recommended variety, as it resists heat and typhoons and yields well, and dropped Kinuhikari; seed supply for general cultivation is to start as early as fiscal 2029
    Public source · Kumamoto Nichinichi Shimbun, 31 Jul 2025 · link
  8. 8
    JA Zen-Noh Niigata set the 2026-crop advance payment (gaisan-kin) for general Koshihikari at 18,500 yen per 60 kg of brown rice, against an initial 30,000 yen for the 2025 crop, a 38% fall, citing rising inventories; general Koshihikari excludes the Uonuma, Sado and Iwafune brands
    Public source · Akita Sakigake Shimpo, 18 Aug 2026 · link
  9. 9
    2024-crop rice full production cost: individual farm businesses 132,112 yen per 10a and 15,814 yen per 60 kg; organised corporate farms 97,057 yen per 10a and 12,090 yen per 60 kg
    Public source · Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, farm management statistics, production cost table, accessed Oct 2026 (2024-crop data) · link
  10. 10
    Private hybrid seed sold at many times the public seed price is still bought when the yield gain lifts the grower's margin
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  11. 11
    Minutes of a regional brand-setting hearing: Mitsui Chemicals Crop & Life Solutions, breeder and seed seller of the hybrid rice Mitsuhikari, did not produce Mitsuhikari seed in 2025 and ended seed sales at the end of March 2025; as a first-generation hybrid, seed saved on the farm will not keep the same quality; the company applied to abolish the brand in all 19 prefectures where it was set; one public comment asked the company to pass the variety to a third party
    Public source · Chugoku-Shikoku Regional Agricultural Administration Office, minutes of the 15 Dec 2025 hearing (file dated Jan 2026) · link
  12. 12
    Core agricultural workers numbered 1.036 million (103万6千人) in 2025, less than half the 2.4 million of 2000; their average age was 67.7 in 2025, 0.1 years lower than in 2020; those aged 65 and over (721,000) were 69.6% of the total
    Public source · Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, FY2025 annual report on food, agriculture and rural areas, 2026 · link
  13. 13
    JA Zen-Noh was expected to miss its 2025-crop collection target of about 30% of production (2.27 million tonnes) despite raising advance payments; the 2024-crop collection rate fell to 26% (1.79 million tonnes); non-JA buyers have grown and farmers increasingly sell directly; initial 2025 advance payments were 30,000 yen per 60 kg for Niigata Koshihikari, up 13,000 yen
    Public source · Akita Sakigake Shimpo, 18 Dec 2025 · link
  14. 14
    Taste is the gatekeeper trait in Japanese rice; a yield or input-saving trait fails if taste slips
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice seed chain
  15. 15
    Labour shortage and part-time farming are the main constraint on rice farms; direct seeding and fewer input passes are valued
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  16. 16
    Farmers buy rice seed through the local agricultural co-operative and seldom question the prefecture's recommended-variety system
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  17. 17
    Rice growers renew their seed with purchased seed almost every season rather than saving their own
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers
  18. 18
    Kanagawa Prefecture selected Nijinokirameki, bred by the National Agriculture and Food Research Organization, as a recommended variety because it is heat-tolerant and high-yielding; as of the end of fiscal 2024 it was a recommended variety in 6 prefectures; JA co-operatives began taking orders in November 2025 for seed to be sown in 2026
    Public source · Kanagawa Prefecture press release, 4 Nov 2025 · link
  19. 19
    Public breeders have little contact with farmers, and some researchers are frustrated that the extension system decides which varieties farmers can get
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan public rice breeders
  20. 20
    Rice is sold by producing-area brand, and famous-area Koshihikari commands the top price
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice wholesalers and retailers
  21. 21
    Niigata Prefecture developed the heat-tolerant variety Niigata 124 because Koshihikari grain turns chalky in high heat; it is heat-tolerant and resists lodging, its taste is comparable to Koshihikari, it is aimed at business use such as bento and rice balls and at export, and it is in field trials across the prefecture
    Public source · Niigata Prefecture, Sanjo agricultural extension page, field training of 6 Aug 2026, updated 29 Oct 2026 · link
  22. 22
    Researchers could not say what makes a rice variety succeed: one said the price, another said the name
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan public rice breeders
  23. 23
    2026-crop JA advance payments in Hokkaido and the three Hokuriku-Shinetsu prefectures were down about 20-40% year on year; farmers fear the payments will not cover production costs, and JAs are considering later supplementary payments
    Public source · Akita Sakigake Shimpo, 20 Aug 2026 · link
  24. 24
    In August 2026 the relative transaction price of 2025-crop rice was an all-brand average of 31,556 yen per 60 kg of brown rice, down 930 yen (3%) from the previous month
    Public source · Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, press release on 2025-crop relative transaction prices (August 2026), 18 Sep 2026 · link
  25. 25
    Planned 2026 table-rice area was 1,363,000 ha (136万3千ha), 4,000 ha below the previous year's actual and still at a high level; with an average harvest, output would be 7.33 million tonnes, above the government's assumed maximum demand of 7.11 million tonnes; retail prices could fall
    Public source · Akita Sakigake Shimpo, 20 May 2026 · link
  26. 26
    Newly harvested rice prices were increasingly likely to fall in 2026 after two years of increases; Miyazaki early-season Koshihikari advance payments were set at 18,000 yen per 60 kg of brown rice, down 45% from 32,600 yen in 2025; the supermarket average was above 4,000 yen per 5 kg until January and fell below 3,500 yen in the first week of July; the state stockpile fell to about 320,000 tonnes against an appropriate level of about 1 million tonnes
    Public source · Jiji Press, reported by The Nation, 17 Jul 2026 · link
  27. 27
    A private seed developer that pairs seed with field advisers and buys back the rice replaces services the co-operative used to give
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan private rice seed developers
  28. 28
    Knowledge of biotechnology at farm level is very limited, and consumer hostility to genetically modified food makes labelling decisive for rice
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice growers and rice traders
  29. 29
    Retailers label variety, fertiliser and the number of chemical applications on their own-label rice packs
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice retailers
  30. 30
    The co-operative does much more than sell seed: it collects and pays for the rice, supplies inputs and gives advice, though its grip on farmers is eroding
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japan rice co-operatives
  31. 31
    Rice farmers adopt a new variety only after they see it succeed on demonstration plots and on a large scale nearby
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Asian rice seed markets

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Rice in Japan