Partner search · Expert interview

Why Malaysian plantations still leave palm trunks in the field, and what would make an estate sell

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Malaysia
Industry
Palm oil estates and oil palm biomass
Length
≈ 30 min read
MPOBMPOCCKPKMIDAFELDAFELCRARISDANextgreen GlobalKumpulan Sawit Kinabalu
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with oil palm plantation estate and engineering managers, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts; every figure comes from a 2024–2026 source, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • Old trunks are chipped and left as mulch under zero-burn replanting, and with the mill-gate bunch price at RM930.00 a tonne in 2025, managements keep biomass low on the list. 1 2 3
  • Nearly 520,000 hectares of palms are ageing, yet only 114,000 hectares, 2.0% of the planted area, were replanted in 2024 against a recommended 4 to 5 per cent. 4 5
  • Trunks spoil within days and palm trees are 70% to 80% water, so collection only works close to a user and on a felling rhythm. 6 7 8
  • Estate groups come first because they replant on a schedule; the Felda schemes (about 870,000 hectares) bring scale but slow agreements; independent smallholders come last. 4 9 10
  • The MSPO biomass chain of custody needs certified suppliers, and certified area is 96.22 per cent for commercial estates but 60.11 per cent for organised smallholders. 11 12
  • The ministry's biomass page lists biosugars and bioalcohols as potential uses of trunks, not current ones, and a RM60 million collection centre is planned at Sandakan. 13 14

Transcript

01Why the trunks stay where they fall

KAKIRA Analyst

Thanks for making time. When you replant, what actually happens to the old trunks?

EXExpert

They get chipped and they stay in the field. The excavator pushes the old palms over, the chipper goes along the rows, and the pieces are left between the new rows as mulch. Under zero-burn replanting that is simply the standard way, and in our books it is not waste at all, it is natural fertiliser and soil cover for the young palms. 1 When an outsider says there are so many trunks just lying there, I understand the thinking, but on the estate that pile is already doing a job. 1

The second reason is the oil price. MPOB put the average crude palm oil price at RM4,292.50 a tonne for last year, and the fresh fruit bunch price at the mill gate averaged RM930.00 a tonne, up from RM875.00 the year before. 2 When the bunches pay like that, management's head is in yield, harvesting labour and mill throughput. Biomass gets filed as low priority with low returns. 3

KAKIRA Analyst

So nobody has tried to buy them?

EXExpert

People have asked, and not only once. The pattern I know is that the approach arrives, head office listens politely, and the answer comes back that we are a palm oil company and would rather not run a new process on the side. That is more a question of habit than of money. 15

And one thing for any outsider: plantations don't give feedstock away. If you want trunks you come with a partnership, with something in it for the estate, not with a request letter. 16

02How much is due, and how fast

KAKIRA Analyst

On paper the pool looks huge. How would you size it as an estate man?

EXExpert

On paper, yes. MPOB's table for December shows 5,700,050 hectares planted. Of that, 5,043,478 hectares, 88.5%, are mature and 656,572 hectares, 11.5%, are immature. 17 Most of the immature area is replanted blocks, so their old trunks are already gone, chipped into the soil. 2 1 Don't count the whole planted area as a trunk pool, because most of it is still standing and still earning. 17

What I would look at is the ageing part. The minister's own number is nearly 520,000 hectares of ageing palms. 4 Past 25 to 27 years the yield could fall to 4 or 5 tonnes a hectare, against up to 28 tonnes for good mature palms, so in those blocks the arithmetic already says replant. 18

The catch is the pace. Malaysia replanted 114,000 hectares in 2024, 2.0% of the planted area, down from 132,000 hectares in 2023, while the recommended rate is 4 to 5 per cent, about 285,000 hectares a year. 5 So the trunks exist, but they come out of the ground more slowly than the maths suggests. 5

KAKIRA Analyst

Who replants on time and who doesn't?

EXExpert

The estates, because they have the capital and a schedule. Across 2014 to 2024 the averages were 2.5 per cent a year for large estates, 1 per cent for organised smallholders and 0.7 per cent for independent smallholders. 4 Smallholders also hold 14.6 per cent of the planted area, so a good part of the old-palm problem is a smallholder problem. 4

And even inside one estate group, felling is phased across scattered estates. You get trunks at one estate for a spell, then nothing there for a long time, while the next block is on another estate, possibly far away. That is irregular supply in both time and place. 8

03Time, water and distance

KAKIRA Analyst

Say a buyer does want trunks. What breaks first?

EXExpert

Time. A felled trunk starts to go bad with fungus within days, so you cannot stack it in a yard and wait for the truck to be organised. Collection and storage become the constraint, not the cutting. 6

Then weight. Palm trees are 70% to 80% water, 7 so I'd say what a buyer pays to haul is mostly water. For the lumber and plywood mills that do take trunks, it only works close to the mill, and they pay per trunk with transport on top. 19

KAKIRA Analyst

Sabah is trying collection hubs. Does that solve it, and is the Peninsula different?

EXExpert

It goes the right way. The Sandakan collection and processing centre, announced at about RM60 million, is planned by Nextgreen and Kumpulan Sawit Kinabalu under the National Biomass Action Plan, in an area where biomass is estimated at 13.04 million tonnes, of which 2.53 million tonnes are palm trunks. 14 A hub changes the question from who will haul this to who will deliver it to the gate. But it only works if the surrounding estates keep felling to a rhythm. 8

On the Peninsula the shape is different. Pahang with 745,445 hectares and Johor with 675,558 hectares are the biggest peninsular states, and the Peninsula holds 44.6% of the national area against 55.4% for Sabah and Sarawak. 17 Those are the two states I'd draw a circle around first, simply because that is where the planted area is. 17 An earlier report described a demonstration plant in Kluang where researchers from Malaysia and Japan were testing how to turn felled trunks into fibre and fuel pellets. 7

04Who a buyer has to sit down with

KAKIRA Analyst

If I'm a buyer, who do I partner with? Walk me through the kinds.

EXExpert

First the estate groups. They replant to a schedule, which is exactly what a buyer needs. 4 They are also the slowest to say yes, for the habit I mentioned: they want to protect the oil business. 15

Second the mills, and I'm careful here. The MSPO biomass scheme lists palm oil mills among biomass suppliers, but it lists trunk chip and trunk fibre as products from plantations and estates. 11 A mill-side contact may help with trucks and local knowledge, but I would not mistake that for a trunk supply deal. 11

Third the settler schemes. Felda alone oversees about 870,000 hectares, and 490,000 of that went to settlers. 9 The MSPO scheme document puts those holdings in the organised smallholder group, together with land managed by Felcra and Risda. 11 These are many smallholders plus a lot of bureaucracy, so supply agreements take a long time. 10

KAKIRA Analyst

Why would a settler scheme care about trunks at all?

EXExpert

They care about the family's income during replanting. Felda's obligations to settlers include income support for up to five years during replanting, and the report warns that replanting costs could reach RM900 million a year. 9 So a trunk payment is a small thing next to the real question of how a household lives until the first harvest. My honest view: pitch the trunk deal to the scheme management, not to the settler, and expect it to be slow. 10

Independent smallholders are harder still. There are over 450,000 smallholders in the country, 5 and I can't see a buyer signing them one by one. They are slow on paperwork and, as the replanting averages show, slow on replanting. I haven't seen a pooled arrangement for trunks work at scale, and I would not build a plant on it. 10 4

05Price, and what would make an estate sell

KAKIRA Analyst

Is there a price at which an estate sells?

EXExpert

I can't give you a number and I'd be careful with anyone who does. There is no published market for trunks like there is for bunches, where the mill-gate price is public. 2 The only thing I've seen paid as a habit is the lumber and plywood mills paying per trunk, with transport on top, and only close to the mill. 19

What I can describe is the shape of the answer. The buyer has to beat 'chip and leave', which costs the estate nothing and gives something back to the soil. 1 The buyer has to take the trunk off the block fast, because the replanting crew cannot wait for you. 6 And the buyer should carry all the work, loading and hauling included, so the estate does not feel it is running a new business. 15

Right now the oil price is firm, so biomass is not at the top of anyone's list. 2 3 I'd guess it gets more attention when oil weakens, but that is a guess, not something I have seen. 3

KAKIRA Analyst

Does the national biomass plan change the picture?

EXExpert

It tells you the direction. The plan was launched on 7 December 2023 and puts total biomass potential at 182 million tonnes a year, nearly 90% from plantations. The ministry lists the trunk's uses today as plywood, blockboard, palm wood and pellets. Note which column the sugars and alcohols sit in: biosugars and bioalcohols are listed as potential, not current. 13

In Sabah there is an extra layer. A planned RM400 million facility at Lahad Datu counts on about 20 million tonnes of biomass, mainly from about 124 mills, and the same report cites the Sabah Biomass Policy and a 7.5% export tax on biomass as factors shaping the industry. 20 Ask the state office what applies to your exact product before you assume anything. 20

06MSPO and the sustainability questions

KAKIRA Analyst

Where does MSPO touch a trunk deal?

EXExpert

In two places. First, the estate's own certificate. Under MSPO 2.0, as at 31 August 2025, 96.22 per cent of commercial estate area was certified, 92.20 per cent of independent smallholder area and 60.11 per cent of organised smallholder area. 12 So the weak spot is the schemes, which are exactly the partners where I told you agreements are slowest. 12 10

Second, the chain of custody for biomass. Trunk chip and trunk fibre are named in the scheme document as products from plantations and estates, and every operating unit that supplies biomass must hold a valid MSPO certificate for the product to qualify. The scheme tests sustainability, traceability and greenhouse gas emissions, and allows segregated or mass-balance models. 11

KAKIRA Analyst

What are the sustainability worries on your side?

EXExpert

Two. Soil first: if you take the trunks out you take the mulch away from the young palms, so an estate manager wants to know what goes back. 1

Second, paperwork and reputation. MSPO 2.0 sets a deforestation cut-off date of 31 December 2019, adds supply chain traceability and, according to the European Forest Institute, lines up with the requirements of the EUDR. 12 A trunk buyer who cannot show where the material came from creates a risk for the estate's whole palm oil chain, not just for the trunks. That is why our compliance team gets a vote in any trunk deal. 12

07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

If a Japanese or Korean company asked you how to start, what would you tell them?

EXExpert

Start with one estate group and one replanting schedule, not with a national supply promise. Ask for the felling plan for the blocks coming out, block by block, and put your collection point where those blocks are. 8 Offer to carry the work of collection and hauling. 15 And bring the certification paperwork with you from day one. 11

Don't build the plan on smallholders at the start. 10 And don't start from the national planted area either. Start from the ageing blocks: nearly 520,000 hectares are ageing, and that is the number that matters. 4

KAKIRA Analyst

Last question. What worries you, and what would change your mind?

EXExpert

My worry is the pace. If replanting stays near 2.0% of the area, the old palms stay standing and the trunks never come out in a rhythm you can plan around. 5 The government put aside RM100 million a year for 2024 and 2025 and the minister is asking for RM280 million a year for five years for smallholder replanting, 4 while the plan on the table for smallholders is RM1.4 billion over five years in total, not annually. 21 I'd want to see that money reach the blocks before I told a board to count on trunks. 21

What would change my mind the other way is simple: a buyer who shows up with a signed plan for collection, takes the trunks off the block within days, holds the paperwork and offers a term the board can understand. Then I would walk it into the boardroom myself. 6 15

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    Felled trunks are almost all chipped and left between the rows as mulch under zero-burn replanting, valued as natural fertiliser and soil cover
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  2. 2
    MPOB, Overview of the Malaysian Oil Palm Industry 2025: planted area rose 1.6% to 5.70 million hectares from 5.61 million hectares in 2024, mainly from more immature palms after replanting; the average CPO price was RM4,292.50 per tonne against RM4,179.50 in 2024; the mill-gate FFB price averaged RM930.00 per tonne in 2025 against RM875.00 in 2024
    Public source · Malaysian Palm Oil Board, Mar 2026 · link
  3. 3
    When palm oil prices are high, plantation managements focus on oil and treat biomass as a low priority with low returns
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  4. 4
    Ageing palms now cover nearly 520,000 hectares nationwide; replanting averaged 2% a year over 2014-2024 against a 4% industry standard, with independent smallholders at 0.7 per cent, organised smallholders at 1 per cent and large estates at 2.5 per cent; RM100 million a year was allocated for replanting in 2024 and 2025 and the plantation minister is seeking RM280 million a year for five years; smallholders hold 14.6 per cent of the planted area
    Public source · New Straits Times, 21 Aug 2025 · link
  5. 5
    Malaysia replanted 114,000 hectares, or 2.0 per cent of its total planted area, in 2024, down from 132,000 hectares (2.3 per cent) in 2023; the recommended annual target is 4 to 5 per cent, or approximately 285,000 hectares per year; the country has over 450,000 smallholders
    Public source · Bernama, 25 Feb 2025 · link
  6. 6
    Felled trunks deteriorate from fungus within days, so storage and collection are a constraint
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  7. 7
    Researchers from Malaysia and Japan are testing a demonstration plant in Kluang that turns felled palm trunks into fibres and fuel pellets; palm trees are 70% to 80% water and produce huge amounts of sap
    Public source · Reccessary (Nikkei Asia report), 9 May 2024 · link
  8. 8
    Replanting is phased across scattered estates, so trunk supply is irregular in timing and in location
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  9. 9
    Felda oversees about 870,000 hectares, of which 490,000 hectares went to settlers; replanting costs could reach RM900 million annually; Felda supports settlers with income support for up to five years during replanting
    Public source · The Edge Malaysia, 6 Oct 2026 · link
  10. 10
    Large settler schemes are made up of many smallholders plus bureaucracy, which makes supply agreements slow
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  11. 11
    MSPO Certification Scheme Document, Chain of Custody of Oil Palm Biomass (MS2751:2022), published 1 Feb 2024: oil palm trunk chip and trunk fibre are listed as products from plantations and estates; independent and organised smallholders hold less than 40.46 hectares, and organised smallholders include holdings managed by FELDA, FELCRA, RISDA and other agencies; palm oil mills are also listed as biomass suppliers; every operating unit supplying biomass must hold a valid MSPO certificate; the scheme covers sustainability requirements, traceability and GHG emissions, and allows segregation and mass balance models
    Public source · Malaysian Palm Oil Certification Council (MPOCC), 1 Feb 2024 · link
  12. 12
    As at 31 Aug 2025 the MSPO 2.0 certified area stood at 754,822.28 ha (92.20 per cent) for independent smallholders, 397,310.80 ha (60.11 per cent) for organised smallholders and 3,977,039.92 ha (96.22 per cent) for commercial estates; MSPO 2.0 sets a deforestation cut-off date of 31 Dec 2019, adds supply chain traceability requirements and, according to the European Forest Institute, aligns with the requirements of the EUDR
    Public source · New Straits Times, 15 Oct 2025 · link
  13. 13
    Oil palm trunk (OPT) is the main stem that becomes available when the tree is felled during replanting; OPT is used today for plywood, blockboard, palm wood and pellets, with biosugars and bioalcohols listed as potential uses; the National Biomass Action Plan 2023-2030 was launched on 7 December 2023 and puts total biomass potential at 182 million metric tonnes a year, nearly 90% from plantation biomass
    Public source · Ministry of Plantation and Commodities (KPK), biomass page, last updated 24 Sep 2025 · link
  14. 14
    A RM60 million palm biomass collection and processing centre is planned in Sandakan, Sabah, to be built by Nextgreen Global Bhd and Kumpulan Sawit Kinabalu as one of the initiatives under the National Biomass Action Plan 2023-2030; oil palm biomass available in the Sandakan region is estimated at 13.04 million tonnes, including 8.19 million tonnes of fronds and 2.53 million tonnes of palm trunks
    Public source · MIDA, 5 Mar 2024 · link
  15. 15
    Plantation management prefers to stick to palm oil rather than venture into new processes; estates have been approached to sell trunks before without management interest
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  16. 16
    Any biomass venture needs a supply partnership with plantation groups; plantations will not give feedstock away
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  17. 17
    MPOB planted-area table as at December 2025: 5,700,050 ha in total, of which 5,043,478 ha (88.5%) matured and 656,572 ha (11.5%) immature; Sabah and Sarawak hold 55.4% and Peninsular Malaysia 44.6%; Pahang (745,445 ha) and Johor (675,558 ha) are the largest Peninsular states
    Public source · Malaysian Palm Oil Board, Dec 2025 data · link
  18. 18
    Mature oil palms can yield up to 28 tonnes per hectare; delaying replanting beyond 25 to 27 years of a tree's life could cut yields to 4 or 5 tonnes per hectare
    Public source · The Vibes, 5 Aug 2025 · link
  19. 19
    Trunks are not free: lumber and plywood mills pay per trunk plus transport, and only near the mills
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Peninsular Malaysia
  20. 20
    Legenda Biomass plans a RM400 million biomass facility at POIC Lahad Datu, Sabah, using an estimated 20 million metric tonnes of biomass mainly from about 124 oil palm mills; trunks come from old palms felled for replanting; the article cites the Sabah Biomass Policy and a 7.5% export tax on biomass as factors expected to have a major bearing on the industry
    Public source · MIDA, 13 Dec 2024 · link
  21. 21
    Under the 13th Malaysia Plan the government is expected to allocate RM1.4 billion over five years to help smallholders replant ageing oil palms; the article stresses RM1.4 billion in total, not annually
    Public source · New Straits Times, 5 Aug 2025 · link

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Palm biomass in Malaysia