Pricing & margins · Expert interview

Tendering marine lubricants from Singapore: how a deep-sea operator switches brands on price, and what stops it

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Singapore
Industry
Marine lubricants
Length
≈ 30 min read
Maritime and Port Authority of SingaporeInternational Maritime OrganizationDNVChevron Marine LubricantsCloselinkSteamship MutualArgus MediaVPS
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with purchasing and technical managers at large and mid-size shipping companies, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts, mostly in Japanese shipping, and the answers say so where it matters; every figure comes from a public source, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • The biggest saving in a lubricant tender is often litres, not the price per litre: measured cylinder oil feed rates average 1.05 g/kWh, over 35% above the engine makers' minimum, and a feed-rate reduction on an average vessel could save more than 25,000 litres a year. 1
  • Large operators choose the supplier through competitive bidding first, and formulation changes have made switching on price easier; in Japanese shipping the large lines do exactly that after price rises. 2 3
  • After price, buyers look at continuity of supply and at execution: a wrong invoice or order confirmation can disqualify a bidder, while, in Japanese shipping, product quality is treated as equal among the majors. 4 5 6
  • Singapore is where the volume is: 56.77 million tonnes of bunker sales and 3.22 billion gross tonnage of vessel arrivals in 2025, which is why a supplier's presence there is part of any fleet tender. 7
  • The fuel mix is slowly widening, with alternative fuel sales at 1.95 million tonnes against 1.35 million tonnes a year earlier, and the IMO's vote on its Net-Zero Framework was adjourned by 57 votes to 49, so a superintendent plans cylinder oil grades for several fuels at once. 8 9
  • Base oils are oversupplied and spot prices were heading down, which strengthens the buyer's hand, while the insurers warn that the Strait of Hormuz makes supply planning a seaworthiness matter. 10 11

Transcript

01The tender is a price check, but the price is not the one on the sheet

KAKIRA Analyst

You buy lubricants for a deep-sea fleet from Singapore. What do outsiders get wrong about how you tender?

EXExpert

They think we compare the price per litre and award to the lowest. The bigger number is how many litres the ships burn. The oil-analysis data in the trade press says the average cylinder oil feed rate onboard was 1.05 g/kWh, over 35% above what the engine makers recommend as a minimum. 1 When the sample shows a healthy base number and little iron, we step the feed rate down, and for an average ship on a 40 BN oil that could be more than 25,000 litres a year. 1

So a brand that is a little dearer per litre but lets me run a leaner feed rate with confidence can be the cheaper year. A brand that is cheaper on paper and makes my chief engineers nervous will be fed generously, and the saving disappears in the engine room. Nobody puts that line in the tender sheet. 1

KAKIRA Analyst

Does that mean you do not switch on price?

EXExpert

We do switch. A large operator tenders, picks the brand first and then lets the supplier sort out who books the order. That is how our field interviews in Japanese shipping describe the big lines, and it matches what I see here. 2 Formulations changed over the years so that moving from one brand to another is less of a technical risk than it was, and the big lines now switch when prices rise. 3

The condition is always the same: the engine maker has approved the oil and the oil analysis stays clean after the change. A saving that comes with a damaged liner is not a saving. 11

02How the tender runs

KAKIRA Analyst

Walk me through a tender, from your side of the desk.

EXExpert

We start from the approved list for each engine, and the lubrication plan for the ship names the suppliers the engine maker has approved, the minimum quantities onboard and what to do when we must buy from another supplier. 11 Only bidders on that list get the enquiry. Then the commercial team and I compare offers by grade, by port, by delivery terms and by price, and the winner gets the fleet volume for a term. 2

I will say plainly that I cannot give you our discount levels, and I would not trust anyone who quotes a market discount to you in a single number. It depends on the grades, the ports and the term. What I can tell you is how the structure works, and it is less secret than people think. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

Do you deal directly with the oil company or through an intermediary?

EXExpert

Both exist. In the Japanese shipping lines our analysts spoke to, some negotiate terms directly with the oil company but outsource the paperwork to a trading house and consider the margin worth paying. 12 I understand why. Port charges, delivery notes and a contact who answers at night in every port are real work, and a trading house is valued for exactly that. 13

In my own fleet the question is simply whether the intermediary adds more than it costs. Some days it does. And a small operator often picks the intermediary first and inherits the brand, while a large one picks the brand first. 14

03What can beat price: supply, paperwork and service

KAKIRA Analyst

If a competitor offers a lower price, what makes you stay?

EXExpert

Continuity of supply. In the field interviews, stability of supply ranks right after price, above port coverage or flexibility, and it matters most when supply is tight. 4 I have had a ship waiting for oil, and I remember it for years. I put my own safety margin in the stock calculation: daily consumption times the days to the next supply, plus a margin and a contingency stock. 11

A cheap supplier who gives me a stock-out is not cheap. And when I am asked to lower the stock held onboard to save money, I answer that the number comes from that calculation and not from the budget. 11

KAKIRA Analyst

What gets a supplier thrown out?

EXExpert

Paperwork. Getting invoices and order confirmations right goes without saying, and in the interviews a miss is a ground for disqualification. 5 It sounds petty. It is not, because every wrong invoice becomes a day of my accounts team's time and a delay in a ship's replenishment. 5

Quality does not decide it: in the Japanese shipping interviews, buyers treat the majors as equal on product. Competition is on price, supply security and execution. 6 Technical support is different. In those interviews, when one major raises its technical service, it becomes the new baseline, and the others must match it or lose the next tender. 15

04Singapore as the supply point

KAKIRA Analyst

Why does Singapore matter so much for a fleet's oil supply?

EXExpert

Volume and traffic. The port authority reported vessel arrivals of 3.22 billion gross tonnage in 2025, up 3.5%, container throughput of 44.66 million TEUs and bunker sales of 56.77 million tonnes. 7 My ships call here as a routine stop, so Singapore is a port I plan my supply around. 7

That also means every supplier wants to be here, and the competition here is the toughest I face. A supplier that is strong in Singapore but thin in the next ports on my route is a partial answer. For a deep-sea fleet the question is how the supply holds from port to port, not how it looks in one port. 4

KAKIRA Analyst

Does the supplier's service in Singapore still matter, or is it all online now?

EXExpert

More is online, and I use it. One large supplier says its link with a procurement platform cut the supplier-side processing of an enquiry from hours to under 5 seconds, which is a company statement, and I take the saving as real but small. 16 What still decides the relationship is whether a person who knows my fleet picks up the phone. In the interviews, buyers took it badly when a major moved its customer service offshore, and they said the sincerity of the front-line staff counted heavily. 17

05Fuel transition and the cylinder oil decision

KAKIRA Analyst

How is the changing fuel mix affecting what you buy?

EXExpert

Slowly, but it is on my desk. Alternative fuel sales in Singapore rose to 1.95 million tonnes in 2025 from 1.35 million tonnes in 2024, with biofuel blends at 1.36 million tonnes and LNG at 571,400 tonnes. 8 Alternative fuels are still a small part of the 56.77 million tonnes the port sells, so my fleet runs on several fuels for years yet. 8

Methanol is the next one. The port authority selected suppliers from 13 applicants, with licences running for 5 years from 1 January 2026. 18 For me that does not mean a new oil tomorrow. It means that when I order ships, I must ask the engine maker what cylinder oil base number each fuel needs and keep the tender flexible enough to cover it. 18

KAKIRA Analyst

And the regulation behind it?

EXExpert

Uncertain. The IMO members voted 57 to 49 to adjourn adoption of the Net-Zero Framework for a year, and the earliest entry into force would be 1 March 2028. 9 A fleet cannot wait for certainty, so I do not sign a long single-grade commitment. I keep the term short enough to change the grades if the fuel plan changes. 9

06Prices, base oils and supply risk

KAKIRA Analyst

Is the market tilted to the buyer or the supplier at the moment?

EXExpert

To the buyer, on the base oil side. The trade analysis says the base oils market is structurally oversupplied, particularly for Group II, and spot prices were expected to keep trending down into the new year, with new refinery capacity in Singapore adding to the pressure. 10 When we negotiate I ask when the lower base oil cost will show up in the finished price, and the answer is never quick. 10

I will be honest that I cannot see a supplier's margin. The base oil is one cost among several, with additives, blending and delivery on top, so I only know what I am asked to pay. The trade press also notes that Group I base oil is volatile and that cylinder oil prices move dynamically with it. 1

KAKIRA Analyst

And the risk side?

EXExpert

The insurers have started to say what we already feel. One mutual's risk alert names the Strait of Hormuz as a chokepoint for base oils and finished lubricants, and asks owners to review their safety management systems for a disruption to supply. 11 It also says there should be a procedure for buying from an alternative supplier, which is my argument for a second approved brand in the tender. 11

In Japanese shipping, joint contracts mixing suppliers were used to counter price increases, and I like the same idea for a different reason: a second supplier on contract keeps the first one honest and gives me supply when one has a problem. 19

07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

A new supplier wants to win a deep-sea fleet like yours. Where should it start?

EXExpert

Do not start with the lowest price. Start with the approved list and with a clean oil analysis on a trial ship, because I cannot switch without it. 11 Then fix the boring parts: invoices, order confirmations and delivery notes that are right the first time, since a miss can disqualify you. 5

Be present in my ports, not only in Singapore, and have a person who answers. Remember that in Japanese shipping the cargo owner sometimes nominates a supplier, and then my decision is made in another office. 20 And in Japanese shipping some deals are tied to freight business, so you may be competing against a relationship and not a price. 21

KAKIRA Analyst

What would change your mind about how you tender, and what worries you?

EXExpert

If a supplier could prove, ship by ship, a lower feed rate at a safe base number, I would pay more per litre for it. That is the number I would put in front of my commercial team. 1 If I saw the lower base oil prices passed through to finished oil quickly, I would believe the market had really turned in our favour. 10

What worries me is a supply break, not a price. The fuel rules are unsettled, and a disruption near the Strait of Hormuz would hit base oils and finished oil together. 11 In the buyer interviews, supply security came right after price, and in a tight market I think it moves up, because a ship without oil does not earn. 4

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    Analysis of cylinder oil use from the oil-analysis database of VPS: the average feed rate onboard during 2025 was 1.05 g/kWh, over 35% higher than the recommended minimum feed rate of the engine makers Everllence (MAN ES) and WinGD; most 40 BN samples show near-fresh BN; engine makers recommend keeping a safe level above 10-15 mg KOH; with BN above 20 mg KOH and low iron, feed rates can be reduced step by step, which for an average vessel using a 40 BN product could save more than 25,000 litres of cylinder oil per year; the article notes a volatile Group I base oil market leading to dynamic cylinder oil pricing
    Public source · Maritime Logistics Professional, 27 Oct 2025 (using VPS data) · link
  2. 2
    In Japanese shipping, large lines choose the lubricant supplier first through competitive bidding, and then let the supplier decide which trading house books the deal
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  3. 3
    Changes in lubricant formulations made brand switching easier, and large lines now switch brands in response to price rises
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  4. 4
    Stability and continuity of supply rank right after price, above port coverage or flexibility, especially when supply is tight
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  5. 5
    Accurate invoices and order confirmations are hygiene factors: getting them right goes without saying and a miss is grounds for disqualifying a supplier
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  6. 6
    Buyers treat product quality as equal among the major oil companies, so it carries almost no weight in the decision; quality is a hygiene factor and competition is on price, supply security and execution
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  7. 7
    Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore, 2025 port performance: vessel arrival tonnage 3.22 billion gross tonnage, up 3.5% from 2024; container throughput 44.66 million TEUs, up 8.6%; bunker sales 56.77 million tonnes, up 3.4%
    Public source · Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore, media release, 13 Jan 2026 · link
  8. 8
    Singapore bunker sales totalled 56.77 million tonnes in 2025 according to the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore, a record that surpassed 54.92 million tonnes in 2024; alternative fuel sales rose to 1.95 million tonnes in 2025 from 1.35 million tonnes in 2024; biofuel blends grew to 1.36 million tonnes; LNG sales climbed to 571,400 tonnes, up 24 per cent
    Public source · Reuters, reported by Baird Maritime, 13 Jan 2026 · link
  9. 9
    At the extraordinary session of the IMO Marine Environment Protection Committee, 57 member states voted to adjourn adoption of the Net-Zero Framework for one year and 49 voted to continue; the meeting continues in October 2026; earliest entry into force would be 1 March 2028, according to DNV
    Public source · DNV, 17 Oct 2025 · link
  10. 10
    Argus Executive Summary of its Global Base Oil report 2025: the base oils market remains structurally oversupplied, particularly for Group II; spot prices looked set to keep trending downwards into the new year; new capacity in China and a refinery expansion in Singapore added downward pressure; any prolonged disruption would weigh on industrial and marine lubricant demand
    Public source · Argus Media in Lube Magazine, Jan 2026 · link
  11. 11
    Steamship Mutual Risk Alert 131: a vessel's lubrication management plan should cover suppliers approved by the engine maker, minimum quantities on board and a protocol for buying from alternative suppliers; planned stock of consumed oils such as cylinder oil should be calculated as daily consumption times expected days to the next supply, plus an operational safety margin and contingency stock; it names the Strait of Hormuz as a chokepoint for base oils and finished marine lubricants and urges owners to review their safety management systems for supply disruption
    Public source · Steamship Mutual, Risk Alert 131, file dated May 2026, accessed Oct 2026 · link
  12. 12
    Some large lines negotiate terms directly with the oil company but outsource the paperwork to a trading house, and consider the margin worth paying
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  13. 13
    Trading houses and agents are valued for a local-language contact in every port, handling port charges, dependable paperwork and market information during supply disruptions
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  14. 14
    Large buyers pick the brand first; small buyers pick the intermediary first and inherit its brand
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  15. 15
    Technical support works as a ratchet: when one major oil company raises its technical service, it becomes the new baseline that the others must match
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  16. 16
    Closelink, a Hamburg procurement platform, and Chevron Marine Lubricants marked 1 year since completing a system integration with Chevron's OnePort customer portal; buyers handle lubricant orders from enquiry to invoice inside Closelink; supplier-side processing that took hours or overnight now finishes in under 5 seconds (figures as stated by Closelink, a company statement)
    Public source · Bunker Market, citing Closelink, 4 Aug 2025 · link
  17. 17
    Moving a major oil company's customer service offshore is seen as a strong negative by buyers, and the enthusiasm and sincerity of front-line staff weigh heavily
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  18. 18
    The Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore announced on 24 November 2025 that Global Energy Trading, Golden Island and PetroChina International Singapore were selected from 13 applicants as methanol bunker suppliers; licences run for 5 years from 1 January 2026 to 31 December 2030, subject to licensing conditions
    Public source · Reuters, reported by Baird Maritime, 24 Nov 2025 · link
  19. 19
    Joint contracts mixing domestic and foreign suppliers are used to counter price increases
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  20. 20
    Cargo owners sometimes nominate a preferred lubricant supplier to the shipping line, so the key relationship can be with the cargo customer
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies
  21. 21
    Reciprocal deals exist: where the oil company is also a freight customer of the shipowner, lubricant purchases repay a linked transaction
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese shipping companies

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Engine oils and lubricants in Singapore · Engine oils and lubricants: why buyers switch across Asia · Engine oils and lubricants: risks across Asia · Engine oils and lubricants: pricing across Asia · Engine oils and lubricants: competition across Asia