How a Bangkok mall buys lift and escalator maintenance: oil-and-grease or all-parts, and when to leave the maker
Summary
- The maintenance contract, not the machine, is where the lift makers earn: Otis booked $9.4 billion of its $14.4 billion 2025 sales in Service at a 25.1% margin, and at TK Elevator Service and Modernization were 65% of revenue. 1 2
- After the free service period most buildings stay with the maker's service company, and the contract signed that day sets the economics: top-end brands mostly sell all-parts, mid-range brands mostly sell oil-and-grease. 3 4
- The chief engineer recommends and the owner or board signs; at the scale of a listed mall owner, with 17 Central centres in Bangkok and its perimeter and 2.3 million sq m of net leasable area across its portfolio, the contract is a portfolio decision. 5 6
- Parts and repair charges are the sore point: expensive parts and slow response from abroad push buildings out, and an accident blamed on maintenance changes the maintainer, not the lift brand. 7 8 9
- Retail occupancy in the Bangkok region fell to 92.4% from 94.6% and about 330,000 sq m of new space is expected in 2026, so owners are likely to press on maintenance budgets. 10
- The Interior Ministry's inspection rule puts lifts and escalators on the list of systems the owner must have inspected, and bars an inspector from checking equipment he or his staff installed, while the 2025 post-quake request to owners of about 11,000 buildings carried no penalties. 11 12
Transcript
01The lift is the sample, the contract is the product
You run engineering for one of Bangkok's bigger shopping malls. What would you want outsiders to understand first about buying lift and escalator maintenance?
That the lift is the sample and the maintenance contract is the product. Read what the makers themselves report. Otis had $14.4 billion of sales in 2025, and $9.4 billion of that was Service, earned at a 25.1% margin, while its new equipment sales fell 7%. 1 TK Elevator says the same from its side: Service and Modernization were 65% of its revenue, Service grew 5%, and new installation was the soft part. 2
So when the sales team is charming at handover, I remember where their money is. The free service period is the first step of the sales process, not a gift. After it, the maker's own service company expects to convert the building into a long contract, and I would do the same in their shoes. 13
So what actually happens on the day the free service period ends?
Nothing dramatic, and that is the point. Most buildings simply sign with the maker's affiliated service company, because we trust its spare-parts stock and its knowledge of its own machines. 3 The older makers have the depth to back that trust: Mitsubishi's Thai company says on its website that its products are installed in more than 20,000 units in buildings across Thailand and that it has offered its experience for more than 40 years. 14 The independent maintenance companies all know us and they call around exactly that time, but in a prime building they are rarely used. 15
The real decision is the type of contract you sign that day. Oil-and-grease or all-parts. Parts prices, response time, even whether you ever leave the maker, all follow from that one signature. I tell my younger engineers to read the page about what is excluded before they read the page with the fee. 4
02Oil-and-grease or all-parts
For someone who has never signed one, what is the difference?
Oil-and-grease is the cheaper monthly fee. The maintenance company comes on schedule, cleans, oils and adjusts, and when something really wears out you pay for the part as it happens. 4 All-parts puts the parts inside the monthly fee, so the maintenance company pays for what it replaces and the surprise invoice mostly goes away. 16
What outsiders miss is the tier effect. Buyers of the top-end brands mostly take all-parts. Buyers of the mid-range brands mostly take the cheaper oil-and-grease and pay for parts when they are needed. 4 So the contract type tells you how much the maker expects the machine to cost you over its life, long before you read the price. 4 13
Is all-parts simply the better deal, then?
Not automatically. Owners on all-parts tell me it keeps the maintainer careful, because every part he changes is his own cost. 16 But I hear the opposite worry across building services: some clients think the contractor lets equipment run down before he replaces anything, and contractors dislike all-inclusive contracts because they block extra billable work. 17
So each contract has its own way to go wrong. With oil-and-grease you can be sold parts you did not need, and many buyers suspect it. I am one of them. 7 With all-parts you can get the cheapest repair that keeps the lift moving. Either way my protection is the same: I read the engineer's report and I ride the machine myself. 18
03Who recommends, who signs
Who actually decides which contract a mall signs?
I recommend, I do not sign. The building manager or the chief engineer writes the recommendation, and the owner, the managing director or the board signs the contract. 5 So my real job is to make the choice easy to approve: the machines listed by age, the breakdown calls since the last contract, and one clear page on what the monthly fee covers and what it does not. 5
I cannot tell you how any one owner buys, it depends on the owner. But look at the scale of Central Pattana, with 17 Central centres in Bangkok and its perimeter and 2.3 million square metres of net leasable area across its portfolio. 6 At that size the maintenance contract is a portfolio decision as much as a decision for one mall, and the lifts and escalators in my building become one line in a much bigger conversation. 5
And day to day, what do you judge a maintenance company on?
In this order: does the engineer really know the machine, how fast does he come when a lift stops, and is the work clean and followed up. 19 I track two clocks, the arrival after the call and the time to finish the repair, because they are different problems. A quick arrival and a slow repair feel exactly the same to the tenant upstairs. 20
What separates companies is the boring part: written reports, a clean machine room after the visit, how fast a part arrives. Most engineers are polite. Where they fall short is volunteering a recommendation before something fails. 21 Finance sees none of this. Finance sees one line, the monthly fee. 5
04Parts, fees and the 2026 squeeze
Where does the maintenance company make its money, in your view, and how do you test a parts quote?
I have not seen anybody's books, so this is my reading. The bill we argue about is parts and repairs. Many buyers, me included, find those charges unreasonable next to what other brands charge, and some suspect that parts were replaced that did not need replacing. 7 Otis reports a 25.1% operating margin in Service, so the business is healthy, but that number does not tell me which part of my invoice carries it. 1
So I ask for the reason in writing, with the engineer's report, and I ask to see the old part. In Thai that is not very kreng jai, not very considerate towards the engineer, but I would rather be rude than be wrong. 7 Some buildings go further and buy the part on the open market and ask the maintainer to fit it. The maker's company does not love that, but it happens. 22
Can you give me a sense of how much more all-parts costs than oil-and-grease?
I cannot give you my numbers, and the ones you would hear from other malls are not comparable anyway. Every fee is written around the age of the machines, how many floors they serve and how many hours the mall runs. What I can say is that the premium is real, and owners of premium brands pay it knowingly. 4 If a new company shows me its parts schedule, I can tell you very quickly whether its fee is cheap or only incomplete, because I compare it with what other brands charge. 23
Is the mall market itself squeezing those fees this year?
Yes. Krungsri has retail occupancy in the Bangkok region falling to 92.4% in 2025 from 94.6%, and it expects about 330,000 square metres of new supply this year with occupancy at 89.0%. 10 When rent is under pressure the maintenance fee is one of the few costs the owner feels he controls, so every budget season I am asked whether we can step down from all-parts to oil-and-grease. 5 My answer is always the same: you can, but you are moving the risk from the contract into our own budget. 4
05When a building leaves the maker
When do buildings leave the maker's service company, and are the independents real competition?
I see two triggers. The first is parts. Buyers who left told us the parts were expensive, and that response was slow when the engineer or the part had to come from the maker's home country. 8 The second is an accident. If a failure is blamed on maintenance, the building changes its maintenance company, not its lift brand, because replacing the lifts costs too much. 9
Everybody knows the independents, and some are good. But in a prime building they are rarely used, and only a minority of owners would even consider one. Nobody wants to be the chief engineer who moved to the cheaper company the month before something went wrong. 15 Some of the big makers also service other brands. TK Elevator's Thai company, which says it was established in 1997, offers maintenance for all major elevator brands and says it is available 24/7/365. 24 25 So leaving a maker's own company does not always mean going to a small firm. 25
If you did move, how would you do it?
First I would get the maintenance history and the engineers' reports into our own files, because a new company can only start well if it knows what was replaced and when. 18 Then I would invite a shortlist to tender. The pattern I know from building services is that the maker's company is nearly always on it, because its relationship with the equipment gets it there, and after that the choice is mostly price. Reputation only gets you onto the list. 26
And I would not hand the whole building to the new company either. In building services generally, owners of big buildings like to split the work across a few contractors, and there is an old saying about not giving the whole system to one contractor. I would move the older machines first, because that is where the parts argument lives. 8 27
06Inspection, escalators and what the law asks
What does the law ask of a mall owner about lifts and escalators?
The Interior Ministry's building-inspection regulation puts the lift system and the escalator system on the list of equipment that the registered inspector must check. 11 The owner files the inspection report with the local authority every year. 11 A law firm's note from last year describes the pattern as an annual inspection of the key safety systems, plus a more comprehensive inspection every 5 years. 28
That is an inspection duty. As far as I know, who does the maintenance and what the contract includes is still a commercial choice between the owner and the maintenance company. Inspection finds problems on the day. The contract decides who fixes them and who pays. 4
Can the maker's service company also be your inspector?
Not if it installed the equipment, as I read the rule. An inspector may not inspect a building whose equipment installation he, or his spouse, employee or agent, was responsible for, and he may not inspect a building he owns or helps to manage. 11 So the inspector is somebody else, and that is useful to me: a second pair of eyes that is not selling me parts. 7
After the earthquake in March 2025 the Bangkok Metropolitan Administration asked owners of about 11,000 buildings of 9 types to check their safety and report within 2 weeks. The governor said himself that it carried no penalties and was a request for cooperation, because the government cannot inspect every building itself. 12 So in practice the discipline comes from us, from the owner and from the contract, not from an inspector at the door. 9
Escalators in a mall are a different animal, aren't they?
They work all day. Central Pattana counts over 510 million visits a year to its centres nationwide, and the escalator is the part of the building that nearly everybody touches. 6 When the upper section of an escalator at a mall on Rama 4 Road collapsed at its folding point in January 2025, nobody was hurt, the management coordinated with technicians on repairs, and the escalator was closed while the cause was investigated. 29 That is the day the contract type stops being a finance topic. And remember that the escalator system is on the inspection list as well. 11
07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me
A new maintenance company, backed by a Japanese or Korean maker, wants malls like yours. What should it do?
Do not lead with price. Lead with the engineer. In my building the first question is whether he really knows the machine, and the second is how fast he comes when a lift stops. 19 Then show me the small things that separate maintainers: written reports, a clean machine room, parts that arrive quickly. 21
Start with the older machines, where the parts argument lives and an owner is most willing to listen. 8 Do not ask for the whole building at once, because owners like to spread the risk. And be patient: you will usually be one name on a shortlist, and the first contract will be small. 27
What would change your mind about staying with the maker, and what worries you?
If an independent could show me parts and engineers arriving as fast as the maker's, with reports as good, I would put one on the shortlist for the older machines tomorrow. 8 What I would need before moving a whole mall is a record of a failure it handled in the middle of the night, written up the way I like it, with the arrival time and the finish time both on the page. 20
What worries me is that the discipline is voluntary. The government itself says it cannot inspect every building. 12 Owners squeezed by falling occupancy and a wave of new space this year will be tempted to cut the maintenance contract before they cut anything else. 10 An accident is the day a building changes its maintainer, and I would rather my owner learned that lesson from a report than from a police statement. 9
Sources and basis
- 1Otis full-year 2025: net sales $14.4 billion; Service net sales $9.4 billion, up 6%, at a 25.1% segment operating margin; New Equipment net sales $5.0 billion, down 7%; Otis maintains approximately 2.5 million customer units worldwidePublic source · Otis Worldwide, fourth-quarter and full-year 2025 results, 28 Jan 2026 · link
- 2TK Elevator fiscal 2024/2025: sales of €9.2 billion; Service and Modernization made up 65% of total revenue; Service grew 5%, and the release cites 19 and 21 consecutive quarters of positive organic revenue growth across its Service and Modernization lines; softness in New Installation, mainly in China, was more than offsetPublic source · TK Elevator press release, 9 Dec 2025 · link
- 3After the free service period, most buildings stay with the maker's affiliated service company, because they trust its spare-parts stock and its knowledge of its own equipmentKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 4Buyers of top-end brands mostly take all-parts contracts; buyers of mid-range brands mostly take cheaper oil-and-grease contracts and pay for parts as neededKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 5The building manager or chief engineer recommends the maintenance contract; the owner, managing director or board signs itKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 6Central Pattana full-year 2025 results: 17 Central shopping centres in Bangkok and its perimeter (of 41 Central centres); a total net leasable area of 2.3 million sq m, stated after the counts of 44 shopping centres and 16 community malls; over 510 million visits a year to its shopping centres nationwidePublic source · Central Pattana press release, 23 Feb 2026 · link
- 7Many buyers think parts and repair charges are unreasonable compared with other brands' prices, and some suspect that parts replaced were not neededKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 8Buyers who left the maker's service company cited expensive parts, and slow response when engineers or parts had to come from the maker's home countryKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 9An accident blamed on maintenance would make a building change its maintainer, not its elevator brand, because replacing the elevators costs too muchKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 10Bangkok Metropolitan Region retail space: occupancy declined to 92.4% in 2025 from 94.6% in 2024; new supply of approximately 79,000 sq m in 2025; for 2026 new supply of approximately 330,000 sq m is expected and occupancy is forecast at 89.0%Public source · Krungsri Research, Industry Outlook 2026-2028: Retail Space in BMR, 25 May 2026 · link
- 11Ministry of Interior ministerial regulation on building inspection (Royal Gazette, Dec 2005): the lift system and the escalator system are among the building systems the registered inspector must check; there is a major inspection and an annual inspection in between; the owner (or the condominium juristic-person manager) files the inspection report with the local official every year; an inspector may not inspect a building whose design, construction supervision or equipment installation he, his spouse, employee or agent was responsible for, nor a building he owns or helps to managePublic source · Royal Gazette, vol. 122 part 126 A, copy hosted by the Association of Siamese Architects (standing rule; its annual and 5-year pattern is confirmed in N4, Apr 2025) · link
- 12After the earthquake of March 2025 the Bangkok Metropolitan Administration urged owners of approximately 11,000 buildings in 9 types (large and tall buildings, hotels, theatres, entertainment venues, giant billboards) to check safety and report within 2 weeks; the governor said the order carries no legal penalties and is a request for cooperation, since the government cannot inspect every building itselfPublic source · The Nation Thailand, 30 Mar 2025 · link
- 13Lift makers earn the long tail through maintenance: free service at handover converts into affiliated maintenance contractsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 14Mitsubishi Elevator (Thailand) says on its website that its products are installed in buildings across Thailand in more than 20,000 units, and that it has offered its experience for more than 40 years (the company's own statement)Public source · Mitsubishi Elevator (Thailand) website, viewed Oct 2026 · link
- 15Independent maintenance companies are widely known and approach buildings as the free period ends, but they are rarely used in prime buildings; a minority of owners would consider themKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 16Owners on all-parts contracts say it keeps the maintainer careful, because the provider pays for every part it replacesKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 17Some clients distrust all-inclusive maintenance contracts, believing the contractor lets equipment run down before replacing parts; contractors dislike them too because they block extra billable workKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hong Kong building services
- 18Supervisors judge a maintainer by the time spent per check, by written reports and by whether the machine room is left clean, and some suspect unnecessary parts replacementKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 19Building supervisors judge a maintainer first by the engineer's technical skill, then by speed of response to breakdowns, then by quality of work and follow-up on the contractKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 20Arrival time after a call and time to finish the repair are tracked separately and judged differentlyKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 21Engineers' manner is generally fine; where most fall short is proactive recommendations; written reports, cleaning after work and the speed of parts delivery set maintainers apartKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 22Some buyers source parts on the open market and ask the maintainer to fit themKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 23Owners judge fees by comparing with other brands' prices and with the service they actually seeKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Bangkok high-rise buildings
- 24TK Elevator (Thailand) states on its website that it was established in 1997 and installs, maintains and modernizes elevators and escalators (the company's own statement)Public source · TK Elevator Thailand website, home page, viewed Oct 2026 · link
- 25TK Elevator (Thailand) offers maintenance services for all major elevator brands and describes itself as available 24/7/365Public source · TK Elevator Thailand website, service page, viewed Oct 2026 · link
- 26In building services the client tenders among a shortlist and picks mostly on price; reputation only gets a firm onto the list, and a manufacturer's relationship with the equipment helps it get shortlistedKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hong Kong building services
- 27Owners of large buildings split maintenance across a few contractors to spread risk; a common saying is never to give the whole system to one contractorKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hong Kong building services
- 28Under the Building Control Act and the 2005 ministerial regulation on building inspection, owners of buildings that must be inspected (high-rise buildings of 23 m or taller, entertainment venues, hotels with at least 80 rooms, condominiums over 2,000 sq m, multistory factories) must arrange periodic inspections: an annual inspection of key safety systems and a more comprehensive inspection every 5 yearsPublic source · Tilleke & Gibbins via Mondaq, 21 Apr 2025 · link
- 29On the evening of 18 January 2025 the upper section of an escalator at a shopping mall on Rama 4 Road, Khlong Toei, Bangkok collapsed at its folding point; no injuries; preliminary assumption pointed to mechanical failure, exact cause under investigation; mall management coordinated with technicians on repairs and the escalator was out of service and temporarily closedPublic source · The Thaiger, 19 Jan 2025 (citing KhaoSod) · link