Customer voice · Expert interview

Road, sea or air: how a Japanese electronics plant near Hanoi chooses its freight mode, and what it will not pay for

Format
Modelled interview
As of
October 2026
Market
Vietnam
Industry
Logistics and fleet telematics
Length
≈ 30 min read
JETROHai Phong PortCivil Aviation Authority of VietnamViet Nam Customs
Modelled interview. Built from KIRA's face-to-face interviews with logistics planners at Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam, and with logistics operators and corridor officials in mainland Southeast Asia, set in today's market. How the trade works comes from what those people told our analysts; every figure comes from a public source, marked next to the answer.

Summary

  • Road carries about 75% of Vietnam's freight volume and rail only 0.18%, but for a Japanese plant road is the first and last leg, while the international flows go by sea or air. 1 2
  • An electronics plant splits its international freight between air and sea, and trucks only where no rail or port exists; Vietnam's computer and electronics exports reached 107.75 billion USD in 2025. 3 4
  • Northern Vietnam's sea gateway is growing: Hai Phong Port was the first seaport in the north to pass 2 million TEUs, yet only about 5.6% of containers in its port area move by waterway, so the road to the port is the pressure point. 5 6
  • Air is the other leg: the aviation authority targets 1.6 million tonnes of cargo in 2026, up 15%, and planners expect cargo tracking from airlines and shipping lines, not from local truckers. 7 8
  • Planners will not pay more for tracked trucks on short hauls, and some leave the telematics choice to the logistics provider; the rule that puts journey monitoring devices on semi-trailer trucks from 1 January 2025 is what moves the market. 9 10 11
  • Logistics costs remain about 16% of GDP, with a policy aim of 12-15%; a telematics seller wins a planner by showing accurate maps, stable signal and a price subcontractors can pay. 12 13 14

Transcript

01Road is the leg, not the journey

KAKIRA Analyst

You plan freight for a Japanese electronics plant near Hanoi. If I asked you how you choose between road, sea and air, where would you start?

EXExpert

I would start by correcting the question. Road is almost never the choice for the international flow, it is the leg at each end. Our parts come in by sea or by air, our finished goods go out by sea or by air, and the truck takes them between the plant, the port and the airport. 2 An electronics maker like us splits the international freight between air and sea, and we use trucks only where there is no rail or port to use. 3

But do not think the truck is a small thing. The press quotes the transport side as saying road carries about 75% of freight volume in Vietnam and rail only 0.18%. 1 So every box, whatever its journey, ends up on a Vietnamese road at some point, and that is where my day goes wrong. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

What goes wrong on the road?

EXExpert

Time, mostly. Traffic jams, a driver who takes a different route, a gate queue at the port. Japanese firms say it themselves in the JETRO survey: traffic congestion is serious and has a great impact on the economy. 15 I don't need a study to tell me that. I need to know at three in the afternoon whether the truck for the evening vessel has left the factory. 2

02Sea for volume, air for the urgent

KAKIRA Analyst

Take sea first. Why is it the default?

EXExpert

Because of volume and price. Our goods are many boxes, not one precious parcel, and the sea freight is the cheapest way to move them over a long distance. For northern Vietnam the gateway is Hai Phong. The port says it handled its 2 millionth TEU in 2025 and was the first seaport in the north to pass that mark. 5 For us it means more ships, more berths, but also more trucks heading the same way on the same road. 2

The planning habit is simple. Sea is the plan, air is the correction. If the vessel is booked and the production is steady, the box goes by sea and I sleep well. If a line stops for want of one component, then it is air and nobody argues about the invoice. 3

KAKIRA Analyst

And air? Is it only for emergencies?

EXExpert

For us it is a regular tool, not just an emergency one, because electronic parts are small, valuable and time-sensitive. The national aviation authority forecast about 1.4 million tonnes of cargo for 2025, up 18%, and set a target of 1.6 million tonnes for 2026, up 15%. 7 I can only say what I see from the plant side: space is not always easy to get at the busy times, and the price moves. 3

The rule of thumb I give new colleagues: decide the mode by the cost of waiting, not by the cost of the freight. A cheap parcel that stops a line is the most expensive parcel in the building. 3

03The road to Hai Phong

KAKIRA Analyst

Hai Phong is not far from Hanoi. Why is the last leg such a problem?

EXExpert

It is not far on the map. But everyone sends their boxes the same way, by truck. In the port area only about 5.6% of container throughput moves by waterway, and the city has targets to raise the barge volume by 8% in 2027 and then 10%, 15% and 20% in the years up to 2030. 6 I would be happy to see it. But I am a planner, not a believer: until barges show me a fixed schedule I can plan against, I will keep booking trucks. 2

What outsiders miss is that the plant does not buy a barge or a truck, it buys a time of arrival at the terminal gate. If a barge operator can promise that, I will talk. If they promise only a lower price, I will say thank you and send the truck. 2

KAKIRA Analyst

Do you ever consider sending goods by road to a neighbouring country instead of by sea?

EXExpert

I know that people talk about it. From what operators across mainland Southeast Asia say, the problem is the empty return, which roughly doubles the effective cost of cross-border trucking, so sea stays far cheaper except for urgent parts or fresh goods. 16 And trucks of one country often cannot enter the next, so the cargo is transloaded at the border; the border rules matter more than the road. 17 For my plant it is a curiosity, not a plan. 3

04What I will and will not pay for

KAKIRA Analyst

Now the telematics question. Do you ask your trucking subcontractors to use GPS tracking?

EXExpert

I ask for what I need, which is knowing where my box is. How they do it is their business. In my experience some manufacturers leave the telematics decision to their logistics providers and only ask that the cost is not passed on, and the provider chooses the technology. 10 I am in that camp for the short hauls. If tracking raises the freight rate on a short run, the truck does not need it. 9

I would not say the same for every shipper. A large carmaker with a milk-run system runs a control room that watches the subcontractor trucks, raises an alarm when a driver leaves the route and calls him. That is what I saw in carmaker logistics in Thailand, and it works because the fleet is dense and the shipper controls it. 18 My own flows are not like that. 9

KAKIRA Analyst

So who pays for tracking in practice?

EXExpert

Usually nobody, unless the shipper insists. The pattern I know is that telematics adoption among logistics providers follows the shipper's requirement; with thin margins and a price-competitive market, they rarely add cost voluntarily. 19 20 That is why I like the rule on journey monitoring devices: Decree 151/2024 requires semi-trailer trucks, with a few other vehicle types, to install them from 1 January 2025. 11

A tractor-trailer is exactly the kind of truck that carries a container to the port. So some of the tracking cost now comes from the law, not from my budget. I cannot tell you how well it is enforced everywhere, that depends on the operator. 11

05What would make a planner listen

KAKIRA Analyst

Suppose a telematics provider, Japanese or Korean, comes to you. What do you want to hear?

EXExpert

First, maps. Accurate maps, a real-time position matched to what shipping needs, and a price that my local subcontractors can afford. Those are the three things I have heard planners ask for. 13 The small trucking firms are the ones who actually drive my boxes, and if the system is too dear for them, it will not be installed. 20

Second, a stable signal. In the field in Thailand the providers who won were chosen on map accuracy and stable signal, and one rival was dropped after trials for poor maps and frequent dropouts. 14 I believe it. A tracker that loses the truck in a tunnel is worse than no tracker, because people stop trusting it. 14

KAKIRA Analyst

Do you want the tracking from the trucker or from somewhere else?

EXExpert

For sea and air I expect it from the airline and the shipping line, not from a local trucker. 8 For the truck I want it to come together with the service, as part of the price. Don't send me a separate invoice for a dashboard. And if you can show the user results, such as fewer accidents, lower insurance cost and better fuel tracking, then I can tell my finance department something besides discipline. 21

I would add one thing about who to sell to. Logistics arms of trading houses own only a minority of the trucks they manage and subcontract the rest. So you may have to convince the provider, the subcontractor and me, and each of us has a different reason to say no. 22

06Cost, policy and the bigger picture

KAKIRA Analyst

How much do logistics costs matter to a factory like yours?

EXExpert

A great deal, though I do not have the plant's numbers to share, and they would not be comparable. At national level the press says logistics costs remain at about 16% of GDP, and a trade-promotion official talks about bringing them to 12-15%. 12 Whenever someone says that in a meeting, I think of the truck waiting at the gate. The cost is not only the freight rate, it is the waiting and the delays. 15

KAKIRA Analyst

Your business is electronics. Is the volume going to keep growing?

EXExpert

The export numbers say yes. Customs data show computer, electronics and component exports reached 107.75 billion USD in 2025, up 48.4%, around 23% of all exports. 4 I take that as a signal that more parts will fly in and more boxes will sail out. More goods, from my seat, means more pressure on every mode at once. 3

A reminder about the yen: the JETRO survey says that in 2024 the weaker yen led firms to import raw materials from Japan, lowering the local content of goods made in Vietnam. 15 That changes my inbound mix, more imported parts and less local supply, so more sea and air and fewer short local truck runs. 2

07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me

KAKIRA Analyst

What would you tell a firm that wants to sell logistics or tracking services to plants like yours?

EXExpert

Understand the plant's calendar before you pitch. We buy by the shipping schedule, the vessel cut-off and the production plan. Come with a solution to a gate time or a missing truck, not with a product. And never promise a lead time you cannot show with a record. 2

Also start with the long-haul flows that already carry a lot of boxes and the dense fleets that are easy to control, not with a scattered group of small operators. That is where tracking pays first. 18 And expect that the buyer will ask who pays. 10

KAKIRA Analyst

What would change your mind, and what worries you?

EXExpert

If barges could give me a firm arrival time at the terminal, I would move boxes to the water for the Hai Phong leg tomorrow. 6 If a tracking provider could show me a cost that does not change my freight rate on short runs, I would not argue. 9

What worries me is the road. Congestion is the thing Japanese firms keep telling the survey about, and the volumes keep growing. 15 If the port, the road and the airport all grow faster than the connections between them, I will be planning around delays that no tracker can fix. 5

Sources and basis

  1. 1
    An article on multimodal transport states that road transport accounts for about 75% of freight volume in Vietnam, that rail contributes only 0.18% of the market share, and that cargo transport volume surpassed 3 billion tonnes, up 14.1% year-on-year
    Public source · Bao Xay dung (Construction Newspaper), 31 May 2026 · link
  2. 2
    Manufacturers' international flows go by sea or air; road is for domestic distribution of goods and parts, including the haul to the port
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  3. 3
    An electronics maker splits international freight between air and sea and uses trucks only where no rail or port exists
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  4. 4
    Computer, electronic product and component exports reached 107.75 billion USD in 2025, up 48.4%, around 23% of the country's total export turnover, according to Viet Nam Customs data reported by Vietnam+ and republished by the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry
    Public source · Vietnam+ via antidumping.vn (VCCI), 23 Jan 2026 · link
  5. 5
    Hai Phong Port handled its 2 millionth TEU in 2025 at a ceremony on 14 December at container berths 3 and 4 of the Hai Phong International Container Terminal, which makes it the first seaport in northern Vietnam to record container throughput surpassing 2 million TEUs
    Public source · VnEconomy, 15 Dec 2025 · link
  6. 6
    Container transport by waterway is only about 5.6% of total container throughput in Hai Phong's seaport area; targets are to raise the volume carried by barge by 8% in 2027, 10% in 2028, 15% in 2029 and 20% in 2030
    Public source · Vietnam News Agency via VietnamPlus, 15 Oct 2026 · link
  7. 7
    The Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam forecast about 1.4 million tonnes of cargo for 2025, up 18% year on year, and set a target of 1.6 million tonnes of cargo for 2026, up 15% compared with 2025
    Public source · Vietnam News Agency via VietnamPlus, 2 Dec 2025 · link
  8. 8
    Planners expect cargo tracking from airlines and shipping lines, not from local truckers
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  9. 9
    Planners will not pay more for tracked trucks on short hauls: if tracking raises freight rates, short-haul trucks do not need it
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  10. 10
    Some manufacturers leave the telematics decision to their logistics providers and only ask that the cost is not passed on to them; the provider, not the shipper, chooses the tracking technology
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  11. 11
    Decree No. 151/2024/ND-CP requires four vehicle types, among them semi-trailer trucks (together with passenger vehicles with more than eight seats used for transport business, ambulances and road rescue vehicles), to install journey monitoring devices from 1 January 2025
    Public source · VietNamNet Global, 15 Dec 2024 · link
  12. 12
    Vietnam's logistics costs remain high at approximately 16% of GDP; a Ho Chi Minh City trade-promotion official said digital transformation is aimed at bringing logistics costs down to around 12-15% of GDP
    Public source · Vietnam Investment Review, 28 Aug 2026 · link
  13. 13
    Requirements voiced for vehicle tracking: accurate maps, real-time position matched to shipping needs, and a price that local subcontractors can afford
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Japanese manufacturers in Thailand and Vietnam
  14. 14
    Tracking providers are chosen on accurate maps and stable signal; a rival was dropped after trials for poor map accuracy and frequent dropouts
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, carmaker logistics operators in Thailand
  15. 15
    A survey by the Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO) found the share of Japanese firms in Vietnam expecting profits exceeded 64 percent; firms said traffic congestion is serious and has a great impact on Vietnam's economy, and that in 2024 a weaker yen led firms to import raw materials from Japan, lowering the localization rate of goods made in Vietnam compared with 2023
    Public source · Tuoi Tre News, 4 Feb 2025, reporting a JETRO survey · link
  16. 16
    Empty return legs roughly double the effective cost of cross-border trucking, so sea stays far cheaper except for urgent parts or fresh goods
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, logistics operators in mainland Southeast Asia
  17. 17
    Trucks of one country often cannot enter the next, which forces transloading at the border; border rules shape the viability of cross-border road freight more than road quality does
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, logistics operators and corridor officials in mainland Southeast Asia
  18. 18
    Large shippers' milk-run systems create the densest and most controllable fleets; a control room watches subcontractor trucks, raises an alarm when a driver leaves the route and calls the driver
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, carmaker logistics operators in Thailand
  19. 19
    Telematics adoption among logistics providers follows shipper requirements; without them, thin margins stop providers from investing
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, logistics operators in mainland Southeast Asia
  20. 20
    Operators rarely add cost voluntarily in a price-competitive market, and the owner-operator end of trucking cannot afford telematics
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, carmaker logistics operators in Thailand
  21. 21
    Users of fleet tracking report fewer accidents, lower insurance cost and better fuel tracking, not just driver discipline
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, carmaker logistics operators in Thailand
  22. 22
    Logistics arms of trading houses own only a minority of the trucks they manage and subcontract the rest
    KIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, carmaker logistics operators in Thailand

Key points

Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.

More on Trucking and freight services in Vietnam · Trucking and freight services: pricing across Asia · Trucking and freight services: who buys across Asia · Trucking and freight services: risks across Asia