How Vietnam's city waste operators buy garbage trucks: tenders with one bidder left, old fleets and local builds
Summary
- Public packages for compactors can end with a single qualified bidder: in Dong Thap 3 bidders applied for 5 trucks and only one passed, and in Quang Nam the 4-truck package at VND11.88 billion had one bidder. 1 2
- The qualification bar (production record, drawings, certificates, legal translations) can decide who wins, not only price; the Dong Thap winner was also the lowest bid at VND7.56 billion. 1
- Old trucks stay on the books: a district utility in HCMC put 5 trucks built between 2001 and 2006, together with a 16-seat van, up for auction in Aug 2026 at VND258.15 million for the whole lot, while the service life for a special-purpose goods truck is 25 years from manufacture. 3 4
- In the field, buyers trusted used Japanese and Korean imports more than new local assemblies, but now packages go to firms that pass the paperwork, such as the domestic builder that won in Quang Nam, and operators still judge them on rust and parts. 5 2 6 7
- Money is the constraint: Hanoi spent VND2.3 trillion on collection and treatment in 2024 against VND568 billion in fees, so fleet budgets follow the city contract. 8 9
- Sorting at source and volume-based fees (HCMC Decision 65/2026, Hanoi's 3-wheel electric pilot from 1 Oct 2026) may change route design and vehicle mix, while HCMC still sends about 58.7 per cent of its waste to landfill. 10 11 12
Transcript
01A tender with three bidders and one winner
You buy compactors for a provincial city company. What is the first thing an outsider would not expect about how that goes?
That a tender with several bidders can still end with a single winner. Take a package that was in the papers last year: a water-and-environment company in Dong Thap tendered 5 compactors, 2 of 4.5 tonnes and 3 of 3 tonnes, worth VND8.185 billion. Three bidders applied, and only one passed evaluation, at VND7.56 billion. 1 People think price decides. Price decides only among those who survive the paperwork. 13
One of the losers was thrown out on the requirement for a production record of 15 compactors a month over 5 years. Another lacked technical drawings, quality and safety certificates and legal translations of foreign documents. 1 When I write a specification I think about that: it is my protection that the truck will arrive and pass registration, but every line I add makes the field smaller. 13
Does that happen in other provinces too?
It does. This August a company like mine in Quang Nam approved a package of 4 compactors at VND11.88 billion, and again there was a single bidder, a domestic special-purpose vehicle builder, only VND20 million under the package price. 2 A single bidder is not a scandal to us. It is what happens when the ticket to enter is a factory, a record and a warranty. 14
02Who decides and what the spec says
Walk me through who does what inside the company.
I write the technical specification and recommend the vehicle, the director signs, and the package has to fit the annual plan and the contract we hold with the city. 13 Both the old state-run companies in inner districts and the joint-stock ones in newer and suburban districts buy by tender or competitive quotation, so I cannot just phone a dealer I like. 15
The spec starts from the route, not from the brochure. Narrow lanes in the old quarter need small compactors; the suburbs can take bigger ones. 16 That is why the Dong Thap package mixes 3-tonne and 4.5-tonne units. 1 I also write down what the crew does all day: a driver and a loader, one shift, long distances to the dump. The truck has to survive that, not a test drive. 17
Does the winning builder have to be large?
It helps. In Quang Nam the winner showed average annual revenue of VND928.19 billion for 2023-2025 against a minimum of VND16.22 billion, and a factory in Hung Yen with total investment of VND64.71 billion. 2 That is how a builder tells the evaluation team it will still be around for the warranty. Whether a smaller builder can get through, I can't tell you; it depends on how tight the package is written. 14
03Money, fees and the city contract
How much freedom do you have on budget?
Less than people think. Households' fees do not cover our costs, so a vehicle purchase depends on the payment terms of the contract with the city, not on our own cash. 9 Look at Hanoi: in 2024 it collected VND568 billion in fees and spent VND2.3 trillion on collection and treatment, 4 times the revenue. 8 A company in that position buys what the contract allows, not what the workshop wants. 9
The Deputy Minister himself said that treatment tariffs are too low and are a barrier to investment in modern technology. 8 I would add collection to that. When the payment is thin, the cheapest truck that passes the spec wins, and the ageing fleet gets pushed another year. 18
And the new fee rules?
HCMC moved to fees by household size from September under Decision 65/2026. Before, a household of 2 or fewer paid VND42,000 a month and 3 or more paid VND84,000; in one group of areas it is now VND40,000 and VND80,000. 10 I can't tell you how that changes any operator's income, it depends on the contract. But the direction is that the fee should follow the waste, and that sooner or later changes the vehicles we are asked to buy. 9
04How long a truck lives
How old are the trucks you still run?
Older than any outsider would guess. Look at a district public-service company in HCMC that put a lot of 5 trucks and a 16-seat van up for auction on 13 August 2026, the trucks built between 2001 and 2006, with a starting price of VND258.15 million for the whole lot and a deposit of 20%. 3 The badges on that list, Truong Long, Samco, Hino-Samco and Mitsu.Sco, show how mixed the names are in one yard. 3
The rule gives a ceiling: a special-purpose goods truck has a service life of 25 years from manufacture, under the decree on vehicle inspection as LuatVietnam summarises it. 4 A truck built in 2001 reaches that age this year. 3 4 We keep ageing trucks on lighter routes or as back-ups until the very end. 18
Why not replace them faster?
Because a truck that breaks down means uncollected streets the same night. So the question is never only the price of a new one; it is whether the workshop can keep the old one alive and whether parts come quickly. 19 And the money for a new one comes from the contract, not from us. 9 So every year I make the same list: which trucks go to the back-up pool, which stay on the main rounds, and which one I would put in front of the director first if the budget opens. It is a ranking by breakdown calls, not by age alone. 18
05Used imports, local builds and Korean parts
Used imports against new local builds. Where do you stand?
I should separate what I was told in the field from what I do. For years the buyers told us they trusted a used Japanese or Korean truck more than a new local assembly, even without a warranty. 5 The reason was simple: a used import can work as soon as it is paid for and registered, while a local builder makes to order and holds no stock. 20
Today the packages I read about go to firms with paperwork and a factory: in Quang Nam a domestic builder won, and in Dong Thap the winner was the lowest bidder to pass. 2 1 My reading is that new-only specs and a warranty requirement tip the paperwork their way. 20 I can't give you the used-import share of any city fleet, because nobody publishes it. 14
What about the brands, Japanese versus Korean?
Korean brands are valued as close to Japanese quality, with cheaper and easier-to-find parts. 7 For a fleet manager the parts are the whole game. If the part for a chassis comes within the day, I can keep a truck on the route. 19
On local builds, my complaint is steel. Operators say it rusts faster, and a compactor body is a wet, corrosive place to work. 6 A builder who can show me the body after a full wet season, still clean and sound, will win the next package without a discount. 6
06Sorting, landfill and what the fleet looks like next
What is changing in the waste itself?
The volume. Vietnam generates nearly 70,000 tons of household waste a day, and Hanoi and HCMC alone account for 23 percent. 8 HCMC collects and processes nearly 13,500 tonnes a day but only around 38 per cent is treated with new technologies or recycled, leaving approximately 58.7 per cent for landfill. 12 So most of my trucks still run to a tip. A new treatment plant will change where they unload and how far they drive. 12 17
HCMC targets 90 per cent treated with advanced technology by 2030, and the Toc Tien waste-to-energy plant has a proposal to go from 1,000 to 1,500 tonnes a day. 12 A truck bought now has to work in that world. 12
And sorting at source? Does it change the trucks?
It changes the rounds first. In Hanoi, from 1 October, a ward is piloting standard bags and 3-wheel electric collection vehicles, with residents sorting into 4 groups and the residual handed over between 20:00 and 22:00. 11 More than 500 households and businesses are in it, for about 3 months. 11 That is a pilot, and I would not order a fleet from a pilot, but I would watch it. 11
The logic behind it is that those who generate less pay less, with 1 bag per household per day. 11 If that spreads, compactors will still be needed for the residual waste, but the small electric vehicle takes over the narrow lanes. That is a vehicle I would have bought as a small compactor before. 16
07Advice to a newcomer, and what worries me
A Japanese or Korean maker, or a body builder, wants to supply city companies like yours. What should it do?
Come through the tender, and read the qualification page first. The ones that lose are not always the dearest; they are the ones missing a drawing, a certificate, a legal translation or a production record. 1 Find a local partner who can pass the paperwork and show it. A company that wins on price and fails the evaluation does not exist for us. 13
Then sell the after-sales. Parts that arrive quickly and a workshop that answers the phone count for more than a discount. 19 Korean brands built their name on cheaper, easier parts. 7 And remember that many buyers do not decide on their own; the contract with the city and its payment terms decide for them. 9
What would change your mind about local builds, and what worries you?
If a local body stayed free of rust through a couple of seasons and the parts came as fast as for an imported chassis, I would stop asking for an imported chassis. 6 19 That is the test, not a slogan. 6
What worries me is the money. Hanoi's collection and treatment cost was 4 times its fee revenue in 2024. 8 If the contracts do not catch up, fleets get older, and the 25-year ceiling does not care about our budget. 4 And packages that end with one qualified bidder tell me the pool of qualified suppliers is thinner than we like. 2 1
Sources and basis
- 1Dong Thap Water Supply and Urban Environment JSC ran an open online tender worth VND8.185 billion for 5 compactor trucks (2 of 4.5 tonnes and 3 of 3 tonnes); 3 bidders submitted (VND7.56 billion, VND7.99 billion and VND8.155 billion) but only the lowest, Duc Long, passed evaluation and was proposed to win at VND7.56 billion; one bidder failed on the requirement of minimum production of 15 compactor trucks a month over 5 years, another on missing technical drawings, quality and safety certificates and legal translationsPublic source · Kien thuc (Tri thuc va Cuoc song) newspaper, 8 Aug 2025 · link
- 2Quang Nam Urban Environment JSC approved the result of a package to buy 4 garbage compactor trucks: Hiep Hoa Special Purpose Vehicle JSC was the only bidder and won at VND11.88 billion, VND20 million below the package price; lump-sum contract, 90 days; Hiep Hoa's average annual revenue in 2023-2025 was VND928.19 billion against a tender minimum of VND16.22 billion; its factory in Hung Yen (total investment VND64.71 billion) met the technical, warranty and schedule commitmentsPublic source · Bao Dau thau (Public Procurement Newspaper), 27 Aug 2026 · link
- 3Notice of an auction on 13 Aug 2026 (published 28 Jul 2026) by the HCMC asset auction centre for District 3 Public Utility Services Co. Ltd: a lot of one 16-seat van and 5 garbage trucks, the trucks built between 2001 and 2006 and badged Truong Long (2 units, built 2002), Samco (2006), Hino-Samco (2001) and Mitsu.Sco (2003); starting price VND258.15 million for the whole lot; deposit 20% of the starting pricePublic source · Bao Dau thau (Public Procurement Newspaper), 28 Jul 2026 · link
- 4Under Decree 166/2024/ND-CP, as summarised by LuatVietnam, the service life of a goods truck and of a special-purpose goods truck is 25 years counted from the year of manufacture; a vehicle past its service life must go through the administrative steps under Circular 79/2024/TT-BCA (summary of the decree, not the decree text)Public source · LuatVietnam, summary of Decree 166/2024/ND-CP, accessed Oct 2026 (page updated 2025) · link
- 5Fleets were dominated by imported Japanese and Korean trucks, much of it bought used, and buyers told us they trusted a used Japanese or Korean truck more than a new local assembly, even without a warrantyKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 6Operators criticised local steel for rusting faster than imported chassis and bodies, which matters on a truck that carries wet wasteKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 7Korean brands are valued as close to Japanese quality but with cheaper and easier-to-find partsKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 8Vietnam generates nearly 70,000 tons of household waste a day, with Hanoi and HCMC alone accounting for 23 percent; nationwide about 69,400 tons daily with 91 percent treated; in 2024 Hanoi collected VND568 billion in waste fees while spending VND2.3 trillion on collection and treatment, 4 times the revenue; Hanoi's per-person fee was VND6,000 a month in urban wards, with a proposal of VND21,000 from 2025 and VND43,000 in 2026; the Deputy Minister of Agriculture and Environment said current treatment tariffs are too low and a barrier to investment in modern technologyPublic source · SGGP English Edition (Saigon Giai Phong), 5 Sep 2025 · link
- 9Households' fees do not cover the operator's costs, so vehicle purchases depend on the payment terms of the service contract with the city rather than on the operator's own cashKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 10Starting September 2026 HCMC applies household waste collection fees by household size under Decision 65/2026: households of 2 members or fewer previously paid VND42,000 a month and those of 3 or more VND84,000; in one group of areas the new rates are VND40,000 and VND80,000 a month; the city says fees by volume should push residents and businesses to sort at sourcePublic source · SGGP English Edition (Saigon Giai Phong), 1 Sep 2026 · link
- 11From 1 Oct 2026 Cua Nam ward in Hanoi, with the Hanoi Urban Environment one-member company, pilots standard waste bags and 3-wheel electric collection vehicles tied to sorting at source; more than 500 households and businesses take part; residents sort into 4 groups; residual waste is handed over between 20:00 and 22:00; the pilot lasts about 3 months with 1 bag per household per day (10 litres for households, 40 litres for businesses), so that those who generate less pay lessPublic source · Soha (VCCorp), 26 Sep 2026 · link
- 12HCM City collects and processes nearly 13,500 tonnes of household waste daily, but only around 38 per cent is treated with new technologies or recycled, leaving approximately 58.7 per cent for landfills; the city targets treating 90 per cent of domestic waste with advanced technology by 2030; two tech-conversion projects aim for trial operation by December, and the Toc Tien waste-to-energy plant has a proposal to expand from 1,000 to 1,500 tonnes per dayPublic source · Vietnam News, 8 Oct 2026 (Oct 2026), citing the HCMC Department of Agriculture and Environment · link
- 13The fleet manager writes the technical specification and recommends the vehicle; the company director signs, and the package follows the annual plan and the service contract with the cityKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 14Dealers commonly sell both new and used vehicles, and local builders make a compactor body to orderKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Vietnam special-purpose vehicle dealers and body builders
- 15Collection in older inner districts is still mostly done by state-owned companies, while joint-stock companies took newer and suburban districts; both buy vehicles by tender or competitive quotationKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 16Narrow lanes in old inner districts call for small compactors, while newer districts and suburbs can use larger ones; body size is chosen from the route, not from the catalogueKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 17Household waste is collected in daily rounds of mixed waste; each truck is crewed by a driver and a loader, works about one shift a day and covers long distances to the dump or transfer pointKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 18Operators keep ageing trucks on lighter routes or as back-ups until they are finally retired or soldKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 19A truck that breaks down means uncollected streets the same night, so spare vehicles, a trusted workshop and parts that arrive quickly count for more than the sticker priceKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City waste operators
- 20Local builders make to order and hold no stock to avoid price risk, while a used import can work as soon as it is paid for and registeredKIRA field interviews · KIRA field interviews, Vietnam special-purpose vehicle dealers and body builders