Pre-engineered steel buildings: who decides — what practitioners say
Who decides
Practitioner views from KIRA Experts transcripts: modelled interviews built on KIRA's field interviews. How we work: Methodology.
Who specifies
- Contractors bring the engineer into the package so the owner deals with one price and one point of contact. owner-directors of shed contracting firms · KIRA field research (interviews with shed owners, shed contractors and local-authority officials in Malaysia)
- Institutional buildings go through tenders where relationships and price dominate, and the design often comes from the district office. steel fabricators · KIRA field research (interviews with contractors, steel fabricators and building owners in Vietnam)
- On small jobs the owner and the contractor decide; architects and consultants only shape material choice on larger projects. steel building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with building contractors, steel fabricators and industrial project owners in Indonesia)
- A contractor who has never installed a steel system will not recommend it to the farm. building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with poultry farm owners, building contractors and steel fabricators in Thailand and neighbouring Southeast Asian markets)
- Owners of standalone sheds usually buy through a contractor found by referral, while a shed inside a bigger investment is specified by an architect and tendered. factory and shed owners · KIRA field research (interviews with factory owners, building contractors and industry opinion leaders in Southeast Asia)
- Large companies run a tender through their project department, with drawings, a bill of quantities and rounds of negotiation. steel building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with building contractors, steel fabricators and industrial project owners in Indonesia)
- Builders and contractors usually choose the structure, and farm owners tend to follow the builder's recommendation. poultry farm owners · KIRA field research (interviews with poultry farm owners, building contractors and steel fabricators in Thailand and neighbouring Southeast Asian markets)
- Owners rarely build themselves; they hire a contractor they trust, found through peer referral or past work, and that contractor often picks the structure. steel fabricators and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with contractors, steel fabricators and building owners in Vietnam)
Who buys and pays
- Farm owners judge a shed as a cost to keep low next to the birds and feed it protects. poultry farm owners · KIRA field research (interviews with poultry farm owners, building contractors and steel fabricators in Thailand and neighbouring Southeast Asian markets)
- Agricultural owners are mostly sole proprietors with low willingness to pay and doubts about steel corrosion in livestock sheds. steel fabricators · KIRA field research (interviews with contractors, steel fabricators and building owners in Vietnam)
- Commercial and institutional owners often choose a contractor through a relationship or a referral, and lean to brick and concrete because it is what they know. building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with building contractors, steel fabricators and industrial project owners in Indonesia)
- Owners of small steel buildings do not know steel sections and do not want to learn, so they trust the contractor who built a neighbour's shed. owners of small steel buildings · KIRA field research (interviews with shed contractors, steel fabricators, shed owners and building officers in Peninsular Malaysia)
- Shed owners value the completion date above a small saving, because a delayed shed means stock in the rain or a stopped production line. owners of industrial sheds · KIRA field research (interviews with shed owners, shed contractors and local-authority officials in Malaysia)
- Owners who are unsure of a builder copy a neighbour's choice and watch the site every day to check the work. factory and shed owners · KIRA field research (interviews with factory owners, building contractors and industry opinion leaders in Southeast Asia)
Who carries the risk
No field statement yet
Indonesia
- On small jobs the owner and the contractor decide; architects and consultants only shape material choice on larger projects. steel building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with building contractors, steel fabricators and industrial project owners in Indonesia) · Why Indonesian owners still build warehouses the conventional way, and how a steel contractor gets a pre-engineered kit into the job
- Large companies run a tender through their project department, with drawings, a bill of quantities and rounds of negotiation. steel building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with building contractors, steel fabricators and industrial project owners in Indonesia) · Why Indonesian owners still build warehouses the conventional way, and how a steel contractor gets a pre-engineered kit into the job
Thailand
- A contractor who has never installed a steel system will not recommend it to the farm. building contractors · KIRA field research (interviews with poultry farm owners, building contractors and steel fabricators in Thailand and neighbouring Southeast Asian markets) · Why Thai poultry farms still build with concrete columns and light trusses, and what a steel maker must change
- Builders and contractors usually choose the structure, and farm owners tend to follow the builder's recommendation. poultry farm owners · KIRA field research (interviews with poultry farm owners, building contractors and steel fabricators in Thailand and neighbouring Southeast Asian markets) · Why Thai poultry farms still build with concrete columns and light trusses, and what a steel maker must change
Vietnam
- Owners of standalone sheds usually buy through a contractor found by referral, while a shed inside a bigger investment is specified by an architect and tendered. factory and shed owners · KIRA field research (interviews with factory owners, building contractors and industry opinion leaders in Southeast Asia) · Would a Vietnamese SME factory owner pay for a fixed-price pre-engineered warehouse, or rent a ready-built unit?
- Owners rarely build themselves; they hire a contractor they trust, found through peer referral or past work, and that contractor often picks the structure. steel fabricators and building owners · KIRA field research (interviews with contractors, steel fabricators and building owners in Vietnam) · Who wins the small steel building in Vietnam: the conventional fabricator, the pre-engineered maker or the ready-built factory